PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Knight v Goulandris: when an emailed award starts the appeal clock

Knight v Goulandris [2018] EWCA Civ 237 is the Court of Appeal case on serving party wall documents by email. It held that the methods of service listed in section 15 of the Act are not the only ones allowed. An award sent by email counted as served once the recipient actually had it in readable form. Because of that, the neighbour's appeal, filed 15 days later, was too late, and an award of about £55,000 stood instead of the £821,000 his own surveyor had put forward.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

What happened

Mr Knight owned 19 Chester Square in Belgravia and carried out a two-year project from 2013, including a larger basement and work to the party wall. Mr Goulandris owned number 18 next door.

The surveyors disagreed sharply about damage. Mr Goulandris's surveyor assessed compensation at £821,210.49, including £640,000 for alternative accommodation during redecoration. Mr Knight's surveyor disputed the extent of the damage and the cost. The question went to the third surveyor, who on 2 September 2015 awarded £55,001.61.

The third surveyor emailed the award to both party surveyors that morning. Mr Goulandris's surveyor forwarded it to him as a PDF late that night, and he read it early the next day. No paper copy was ever served on Mr Goulandris himself.

Mr Goulandris issued his appeal to the county court on 17 September. Mr Knight said it was out of time under section 10(17). The county court disagreed, holding email was not good service at the time. Mr Knight appealed.

The question for the court

Was emailing the award "service" under section 15, so that the 14-day appeal period ran from the email? Or is section 15 a complete list of permitted methods, none of which (before April 2016) was email?

What the Court of Appeal decided

Lord Justice Patten gave the main judgment. The court held:

  • The word "may" in section 15(1) is permissive. It lists methods that are always good, but it does not rule out others.
  • A party using another method, such as email, has to prove the document was actually received in readable form. The court said the burden is on him "to establish receipt of the document in a legible form".
  • What surveyors generally believed about email, and the government's reasons for the 2016 amendment, carried little weight in reading the Act.

Mr Goulandris had received and read the award by 3 September at the latest. His appeal on 17 September was therefore outside the 14 days. The appeal was allowed and the £55,001.61 award stood.

The 2016 change

The award in this case predated 6 April 2016, when section 15(1A) was added. Since then the Act expressly allows electronic service if the recipient has said they are willing to receive documents that way, at an address they gave, and has not withdrawn that. Knight v Goulandris adds that even outside section 15(1A), actual receipt in readable form can be enough. In practice, treat any emailed notice or award as potentially live from the moment you read it.

Why it matters in practice

The case shows how much can turn on a fortnight. The gap between the two figures was about £766,000, and the neighbour lost the chance to argue it because the clock had already started.

For adjoining owners: if your surveyor forwards an award by email, assume the 14 days have begun. Do not wait for the paper copy.

For surveyors and building owners: email is usable, but keep proof the document arrived and could be opened. A read receipt, a reply, or a forwarding chain all help. Serving in a way you cannot prove invites the argument that time never started.

What to do differently

  1. Agree at the start how notices and awards will be served, in writing, with the email address to use.
  2. When an award arrives by email, note the date and time you opened it.
  3. If you are thinking of appealing, speak to a solicitor that day.
  4. Count 14 days from the first day you had the award in readable form. Aim to file well before the last day.

Frequently asked questions

Can a party wall notice be served by email?

Yes, if the recipient has said in advance that they will accept service by email at a stated address and has not withdrawn that, under section 15(1A) added in 2016. Knight v Goulandris also suggests other methods can work if receipt in readable form is proved, but relying on that invites argument.

Does the 14-day appeal period start when my surveyor gets the award or when I do?

In this case the court looked at when Mr Goulandris himself received and read it, which was within hours of his surveyor. Do not assume you have extra time because it went to your surveyor first. Ask your surveyor to send it on immediately.

Why was there such a big gap between the two surveyors' figures?

The two party surveyors took very different views of how much damage was caused and what repairing it would involve, including whether the family needed alternative accommodation. That is exactly why the Act provides a third surveyor to decide between them.

Could Mr Goulandris have challenged the £55,001.61 figure?

Only by appealing within 14 days under section 10(17). Once that time had passed, the award was final under section 10(16). The Court of Appeal did not consider whether the figure was right.

Related guides

Read the judgment: Knight v Goulandris [2018] EWCA Civ 237 (National Archives)

Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.

Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free

Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.

We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.