Patel v Peters: when one party wall surveyor can act alone
Patel v Peters [2014] EWCA Civ 335 is the Court of Appeal case on the 10-day request in section 10(7) of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. It decided that if a surveyor who has been asked to act replies effectively, even after the 10 days are up, the other surveyor loses the power to go ahead alone, provided they have not already done so. The fee awards one surveyor made on his own were quashed.
What happened
The Patels planned work at 36a Courthope Road in north London that affected three neighbouring properties. The usual two-surveyor arrangement was in place: the Patels' surveyor, the neighbours' surveyor, and a third surveyor chosen by them.
The dispute was about the neighbours' surveyor's fees. He worked them out from his timesheets. The Patels' surveyor refused to go through the timesheets and instead assessed what a competent surveyor should have needed.
On 21 December 2011 the neighbours' surveyor served a section 10(7) request, asking the other surveyor to act. The reply came on 6 January 2012, outside the 10 days. It gave reasons for his approach, proposed his own figure, and suggested the third surveyor decide any disagreement.
The neighbours' surveyor treated the 10 days as having expired and made fee awards on his own. The county court upheld them. The Patels appealed.
The question for the court
Did the Patels' surveyor "refuse" or "neglect" to act effectively, so that section 10(6) or 10(7) let the other surveyor act alone? And does a reply sent after the 10 days still count?
What the Court of Appeal decided
Lord Justice Richards gave the main judgment, with Lords Justices Beatson and Briggs agreeing.
Late replies can count. Section 10(7) does not create a permanent state of default once 10 days pass. If the surveyor acts effectively after the 10 days but before the requesting surveyor has acted alone, the power to act alone is lost. The court said that once effective action is taken, the reason for allowing one surveyor to proceed alone "has disappeared".
The content of the reply matters. The reply here dealt with the actual issue, gave reasons for not reviewing the timesheets, put forward a basis for the fee, and called for the third surveyor. That was acting effectively, even though it disagreed. The court did not need to define exactly where "refusal" ends and "neglect" begins.
The appeal was allowed and the fee awards were quashed.
Why it matters in practice
The ex parte route in sections 10(6) and 10(7) is there to stop one surveyor holding the process hostage by doing nothing. It is not a shortcut for winning an argument with a surveyor who disagrees.
Three lessons follow.
Disagreement is not default. A surveyor who engages with the issue, explains their view and suggests the third surveyor is acting. If you want a deadlock broken, the third surveyor under section 10(11) is the proper route.
Check the position just before acting alone. Even after 10 days, a real reply that arrives first stops the ex parte power. A surveyor who goes ahead without checking risks an award that is quashed, plus the costs of the appeal.
Fee disputes go through the same rules. Patel v Peters was not about any physical damage. It was entirely about fees, which are often where party wall disputes become bitter.
What to do differently
If you are a homeowner and your surveyor says the other side's surveyor has gone silent: 1. Ask to see the 10-day request and the date it was served. 2. Ask whether any reply has come in since, even a late one. 3. If there is disagreement rather than silence, ask why it is not going to the third surveyor.
If you are the building owner facing an award made by one surveyor alone: look at the dates. If your surveyor responded effectively before the award was made, the award may be open to appeal. Remember the 14-day limit in section 10(17).
Frequently asked questions
What is a section 10(7) request?
It is a written request from one party wall surveyor asking the other to act on a particular matter. If the other surveyor neglects to act effectively for 10 days after it is served, the requesting surveyor can proceed alone on that matter. The result has the same effect as if an agreed surveyor had made it.
What is an ex parte party wall award?
It is an award made by one surveyor without the other's participation, using sections 10(6) or 10(7). It is legitimate where the other surveyor refuses or neglects to act, but Patel v Peters shows the conditions must be met when the award is made.
My surveyor replied after 10 days. Does that count?
It can. Patel v Peters held that an effective reply after the 10 days, but before the other surveyor has acted alone, removes the right to act alone. The reply needs to engage with the matter, not just acknowledge it.
Who decides when the two surveyors disagree about fees?
The third surveyor, under section 10(11). Either surveyor or either owner can refer the matter. In Patel v Peters the Patels' surveyor had suggested exactly that, which helped show he was acting effectively.
Related guides
- What is an ex parte party wall award and when is it used?
- The third surveyor in party wall procedures
- Agreed surveyor vs two surveyors: the legal differences
- How to dispute a party wall surveyor's fees
- How to challenge a party wall award in the county court
- All party wall court cases
Read the judgment: Patel & Anor v Peters & Ors [2014] EWCA Civ 335 (National Archives)
Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.
Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free
Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.
We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.