Kirupakaran v Ibrahim: £1.5m Party Wall Claim Struck Out
In June 2026 the Technology and Construction Court struck out a claim of about £1.5 million brought by the owner of a terraced building in Croydon Road, London SE20, after works next door damaged it. The neighbouring former pub was being extended and converted into flats, with excavation and underpinning at the party wall under two party wall awards. Cracking began within weeks and part of the claimant's building was later demolished on safety grounds.
What happened
The claimant owned 166 Croydon Road, London SE20, a mid-terrace building with a takeaway on the ground floor and flats above. Next door, at the end of the terrace, a company owned a former pub at 164 and began a large redevelopment in August 2024: extra storeys, a four-storey rear extension with a basement, and conversion into ten flats. Two party wall awards were made under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 in autumn 2024, covering excavation, new foundations and later underpinning and rebuilding of the party wall.
Cracking and movement appeared at number 166 from August 2024. In June 2025 Bromley Council took emergency action and part of the building was demolished. The owner, representing himself, issued a claim in the Technology and Construction Court for about £1.5 million, relying on the Act, construction safety regulations and negligence. He sued six defendants: the developer company's two directors and another individual, the main contractor, and both party wall surveyors, including the one he had appointed.
What was decided
A deputy judge had already described the claim as hopeless in November 2025 and made an unless order requiring a proper pleading. At a hearing in June 2026, Mrs Justice O'Farrell found the amended particulars still failed. They did not identify the duty owed by each defendant, how it was breached or what loss it caused. In the judge's words they did "not plead any factual or legal basis of claim". Being a litigant in person did not excuse compliance with the court rules.
The directors were not shown to be personally liable for the company's works. Following Gray v Elite Town Management, the court confirmed that party wall surveyors act quasi-judicially when settling disputes and do not owe the adjoining owner a duty over the design or adequacy of the works. The remedy for loss caused by the works was compensation under section 7, as the awards provided. The claim was struck out and the claimant was ordered to pay the defendants' costs.
Why it matters for homeowners
- Under section 7(2) the building owner, here the company, is the party that must compensate for damage caused by notifiable work. Directors and surveyors are not substitutes.
- A surveyor's award is challenged by appeal under section 10(17) within 14 days, not by suing the surveyor later.
- Even where damage is severe and obvious, a court claim must clearly link each defendant to a duty, a breach and a loss.
What to do if this happens to you
- Ask your surveyor to record the damage and seek compensation from the building owner under the award.
- Keep dated photos, engineers' reports and the council's notices.
- Get legal advice before issuing a claim, especially for large losses, and identify the correct defendant.
See our guides on the evidence needed to prove party wall damage and how to appeal a party wall award in the county court.
The lesson: Serious party wall damage still needs a properly pleaded claim against the right party, usually the building owner, not the surveyors.
Source
Approved judgment (High Court, TCC) ([2026] EWHC 1429 (TCC))
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More excavation and collapse stories
Neighbour Extension Collapsed Tenant's Decking: Clarion Pays
A Clarion Housing tenant's garden decking collapsed into the neighbouring garden in March 2023 while the neighbour was building a rear extension. The neighbour's works, which began in December 2022, had also blocked drains and destabilised her fence. A party…
Richmond Terraced Homes Collapse During Basement Works
Shortly before 3pm on 10 September 2024, two terraced houses on Lower Mortlake Road in Richmond collapsed while undergoing refurbishment. The roofs caved in and the upper and ground floors were badly damaged. The houses were part of a redevelopment into 14…
Hackney Rebuild Collapsed; 20 Evacuated From House Next Door
On 24 June 2023 the rear of a three-storey semi-detached house with a basement on Gloucester Drive, Hackney, collapsed from roof level to the ground. The house was being reconstructed and nobody lived there. London Fire Brigade said the collapse was believed…
Gable Wall Fell on Neighbour's Home in Bushey: £40k Fine
On 5 April 2021 a house on Grange Road in Bushey, Hertfordshire, had been stripped back to a shell for refurbishment when its end wall collapsed onto the neighbouring property. A resident next door suffered a broken breastbone and collarbone. The Health and…
All excavation and collapse stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.