Party wall counter notice: what Section 4 lets a neighbour ask for
A party wall counter notice is a notice the adjoining owner can serve, under section 4 of the Act, asking the building owner to include extra work for the neighbour's benefit, such as flues, chimney breasts, piers or recesses, or deeper or stronger special foundations. It must be served within one month of the party structure notice and come with plans and particulars. The neighbour usually pays for the extra work they ask for.
What a counter notice is, and what it is not
People often say "counter notice" when they mean a reply to a notice. They are different things:
- A reply (consent or dissent) is how a neighbour responds to any notice within 14 days.
- A counter notice is a specific right under section 4. It only answers a party structure notice under Section 3, and it asks for additional works to be built into the wall or foundations for the neighbour's own use.
A counter notice is not a way to object, delay or redesign the building owner's project. If you object to the work, you dissent and the surveyors deal with it under section 10.
What a counter notice can ask for
Section 4(1) allows two kinds of requirement:
- Works in or on the party wall or party fence wall (or other party structure): chimney copings, breasts, jambs or flues, or piers, recesses or similar works, that are reasonably needed for the neighbour's convenience.
- Special foundations the neighbour has consented to under section 7(4): that they be placed deeper than proposed, or made strong enough to carry the loads of columns in a building the neighbour intends to put up, or both.
Section 11(7) adds a third use: if the building owner proposes to reduce the height of a party wall or party fence wall under section 2(2)(m), the neighbour can serve a counter notice requiring the existing height to be kept. They then pay their share of the cost of the wall above two metres, or above the height their own building encloses.
You can read section 4 on legislation.gov.uk.
Deadlines and form
| Step | Rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Serve the counter notice | Within one month beginning with the day the party structure notice was served | s.4(2)(b) |
| What it must include | The works required, with plans, sections and particulars | s.4(2)(a) |
| Signal intention | The GOV.UK booklet says the neighbour should tell the building owner within 14 days if they intend to serve one | Booklet |
| Building owner's reply | Written consent within 14 days, or a dispute is deemed to have arisen | s.5 |
When the building owner can refuse
Under section 4(3), the building owner must comply unless the works asked for would:
- be injurious to the building owner;
- cause the building owner unnecessary inconvenience; or
- cause unnecessary delay to the work in the party structure notice.
If the owners disagree about whether one of those applies, the surveyors decide it in the award.
Who pays for counter notice works?
Section 11(9) says the adjoining owner pays the expenses of works carried out at their request or requirement. So the neighbour who asks for a pier or a flue normally pays for it. A building owner can also ask for security before starting such work (section 12(2)). Where the counter notice is about keeping a wall's height, section 11(7) sets the cost share. For the general rules on cost, see who pays the party wall surveyor fees.
Worked examples
Raising a party wall for a loft
A building owner serves a party structure notice to raise the party wall for a hip-to-gable loft. The neighbour plans a similar loft next year and wants a flue and a pier built into the raised section now, to avoid opening the wall again. They serve a counter notice within a month with a drawing from their architect. The surveyors agree it can be done without unnecessary delay, and the neighbour pays the extra cost.
Lowering a garden wall
A building owner proposes to reduce a tall shared garden wall to two metres. The neighbour values the privacy of the higher wall and serves a counter notice to keep it. The neighbour then pays a share of the cost of the part above two metres, as section 11(7) provides.
What does not work
A neighbour who dislikes a rear extension cannot use a counter notice to demand a lower roof or a different design. That is planning territory, or a matter for dissent and the award. See can my neighbour stop my building work.
Example counter notice
Example only. Original wording; adapt and attach drawings.
To [building owner], [address]. Party Wall etc. Act 1996, section 4: counter notice.
I/We, owner(s) of [address], refer to your party structure notice dated [date]. Under section 4(1)(a), I/we require you to build into the party wall [describe: e.g. "a brick pier at first-floor level and a flue, as shown on drawing ref. ___"], which are reasonably required for my/our convenience. Plans, sections and particulars are enclosed. I/We understand the expenses of these works are mine/ours under section 11(9).
Signed ______ Date ______
Frequently asked questions
Can I serve a counter notice to a Section 6 excavation notice?
Not under section 4, which only responds to a party structure notice. Under section 6(3), though, the neighbour can require the building owner to underpin or otherwise safeguard their foundations where necessary, at the building owner's expense; that is dealt with through the award.
Is a counter notice the same as dissent?
No. Dissent means you do not consent and want surveyors to settle the work. A counter notice asks for extra works. You can do both.
What if I miss the one-month deadline?
The section 4 right is lost for that notice. The building owner may still agree to extra work by arrangement, but cannot be required to.
Do I need a surveyor to serve a counter notice?
Not legally, but you do need plans, sections and particulars, so an architect, engineer or surveyor usually helps. If surveyors are already appointed, they will handle it.
Where can I learn about the party structure notice itself?
See our guide to the Section 3 party structure notice and the full Section 2 rights.
This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.
Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free
Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.
We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.