PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Kaye v Lawrence: security for excavation on the building owner's land

Kaye v Lawrence [2010] EWHC 2678 (TCC) is the High Court decision that an adjoining owner can ask for security for expenses under section 12(1) of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 when the building owner is excavating under section 6, even if every bit of the dig is on the building owner's own land. The third surveyor had said security was unavailable in that situation. Mr Justice Ramsey held that was wrong in law.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

What happened

Mr Lawrence owned 124 Panorama Road, Sandbanks, and planned an excavation within 3 and 6 metres of his neighbour's building at number 126. The work was entirely on his own land and involved no underpinning of the neighbour's house.

Mr Kaye, the neighbour, dissented and wanted security before the dig began. The third surveyor's award of January 2010 said a security bond could not be required, because the building owner was not proposing to work on the adjoining owner's land. Instead the award required £2 million of professional indemnity insurance covering the design team and the building owner.

Mr Kaye appealed to the court under section 10(17).

The question for the court

Can an adjoining owner request security under section 12(1) when the building owner's section 6 excavation is wholly on the building owner's land?

What the court decided

Ramsey J allowed the appeal. His reasons, in short:

  • Section 12(1) lets an adjoining owner ask for security before the building owner starts work "in the exercise of the rights conferred by this Act". The rights in sections 6(1) and 6(2) are rights conferred by the Act. They replace the common law position within the 3 and 6 metre zones.
  • A widely used surveyors' guidance publication, the "Green Book", had said security was only for work affecting the neighbour's land. The judge did not accept that.
  • Other rights, such as cutting into a party structure under section 2(2)(f), can also be done entirely from the building owner's side, and damage is just as likely.
  • Liability for loss or damage under section 7(2) covers all work under the Act, so it would make little sense to allow security for some of that work but not the rest.
  • The judge said there is no requirement in the Act that security can only be requested where work is on the neighbour's land.

The award had to be corrected to say that security can be requested when the building owner intends to exercise section 6(1) or 6(2) rights, wherever the work is.

Why it matters in practice

Basement digs, deep foundations and piling are the projects most likely to cause serious damage next door. They are almost always on the building owner's own land. Kaye v Lawrence means the neighbour is not shut out of security just because the digger stays on the other side of the boundary.

That said, the case decided only that security can be asked for. How much, in what form, and whether it is reasonable in the circumstances are still for the surveyors to decide under section 10. The GOV.UK explanatory booklet notes that security is usually reserved for particularly intrusive or complex work. A side extension on strip foundations is unlikely to justify a large bond; a deep basement under a terrace may well.

Security can take different forms: money held in an escrow or stakeholder account, a bond, or insurance. The point is that if the work stops halfway, or damage is caused and the building owner cannot or will not pay, there is a fund to draw on.

What to do differently

If you are the neighbour: 1. Ask for security in writing before the work starts. Section 12(1) requires the request to come before the building owner begins. 2. Say why: the depth of the dig, the age of your house, the cost of repairs if things go wrong. 3. Let the surveyors decide the amount and form. If they refuse in principle because the work is on the other side, point them to Kaye v Lawrence.

If you are the building owner: expect a security request for any substantial section 6 work, and budget for it. A well-insured, well-designed scheme with a clear method statement often leads to a lower figure.

Frequently asked questions

What is security for expenses under the Party Wall Act?

It is money or another guarantee that the building owner provides before work starts, so the neighbour has protection if the work is left unfinished or damage is not put right. Section 12 lets either owner request it in certain situations. The surveyors settle any dispute about it.

When must I ask for security?

Under section 12(1), the adjoining owner's request must be made before the building owner starts the work in question. Raise it in your reply to the notice or early in discussions with the surveyors. Once work has started, the right to request it under that subsection has gone.

How much security will I get?

The case does not set an amount. Surveyors decide what is reasonable based on the scale and risk of the work and the likely cost of putting things right. Kaye v Lawrence only decided that excavation on the building owner's land is not excluded.

Is professional indemnity insurance the same as security?

Not quite. In Kaye v Lawrence the third surveyor required £2 million of insurance as a substitute, and the judge noted that awards commonly deal with insurance. But insurance protects against negligence; it does not guarantee the work is finished or that every repair cost is met. Surveyors can consider both.

Related guides

Read the judgment: Kaye v Lawrence [2010] EWHC 2678 (TCC) (National Archives)

Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.

Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free

Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.

We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.