PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Louis v Sadiq: the cost of party wall work done without notice

Louis v Sadiq (1997) 74 P & CR 325 is a Court of Appeal decision from November 1996 holding that a building owner who carries out work to a party wall without following the statutory procedure is liable in nuisance for the damage, including financial losses that follow from it. The neighbours recovered, among other things, £22,762 in extra mortgage interest after the damage cost them a house sale. Following the procedure later did not wipe out the earlier liability.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

What happened

Mr Sadiq carried out structural work affecting the party wall between his London house and the home of his neighbours, Mr and Mrs Louis. He did not comply with the London Building Acts (Amendment) Act 1939, the London law that the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 later replaced and extended to the whole of England and Wales.

The work damaged the Louises' house. They were trying to sell, and the sale fell through. While they were stuck with the property, they paid mortgage interest they would otherwise have avoided, and plans to build a home abroad became more expensive.

At Shoreditch County Court in May 1995, the judge found Mr Sadiq liable and awarded damages. He appealed.

The question for the court

Was the building owner liable in nuisance for the damage and the consequential losses caused by unauthorised party wall work? And did his later compliance with the statute reduce or remove that liability?

What the Court of Appeal decided

Lords Justices Evans, Henry and Aldous dismissed the appeal.

  • Carrying out the work without the statutory authority was a nuisance, and Mr Sadiq was liable for its consequences, including the lost sale.
  • Later compliance did not excuse what had already happened. Liability continued until the work was authorised, by agreement or through the surveyors.

The damages upheld were:

Head of loss Amount
Extra mortgage interest, November 1988 to March 1993, from the lost sale £22,762
Higher cost of building a property abroad over the same period 79,000 French francs
General damages £12,500
Distress and inconvenience on a separate item £1,500

Why it matters in practice

Louis v Sadiq is old, but it is still cited. In Power v Shah in 2023 the Court of Appeal listed it among the authorities supporting the view that, until the Act is triggered by a notice, the neighbour's ordinary common law rights remain. That is what makes Louis v Sadiq bite: a builder who skips the Act is not protected by it.

The case also shows that damages are not limited to the cost of repairing cracks. Where the damage foreseeably causes other financial loss, such as a sale collapsing and carrying costs mounting, that can be recovered too, if it is proved. That is a much bigger risk for a building owner than a surveyor's award for redecoration.

For neighbours, the lesson is about evidence. The Louises could show the sale, its collapse, and the interest they paid. A vague claim that "the work hurt our sale" would not have produced those figures.

What to do differently

If you are the building owner: 1. Serve the correct notice before touching a party wall. The Act's procedure is what turns a potential nuisance into authorised work. 2. If you have already started without notice, stop and serve one now. Louis v Sadiq says liability runs until the work is authorised, so the sooner, the better.

If you are the neighbour and your sale or letting is affected: 1. Keep every document: offers, the buyer's withdrawal and their reasons, survey reports, and mortgage statements. 2. Tell the building owner in writing about the financial loss as it happens. 3. Take legal advice early. Consequential losses of this kind are usually pursued through the courts rather than a party wall award.

Frequently asked questions

Does Louis v Sadiq still apply under the 1996 Act?

It was decided under the 1939 London Act, but the courts treat the 1996 Act as built on the same scheme. The Court of Appeal relied on it in Power v Shah in 2023, so its reasoning on liability for unauthorised work remains good guidance.

Can I claim for a lost house sale caused by my neighbour's building work?

Possibly. Louis v Sadiq shows that foreseeable financial loss flowing from damage, such as extra mortgage interest after a failed sale, can be recovered. You must prove the loss and the link to the work, so documents matter more than anything.

Does serving a notice late make the building owner safe?

Not for what already happened. The court held that later compliance did not remove liability for the earlier nuisance. A late notice does bring the work going forward under the Act, which helps both sides.

Is this the same as compensation under section 7(2)?

Similar, but not the same route. Section 7(2) requires compensation for loss or damage caused by authorised work, usually settled by surveyors. Louis v Sadiq was a nuisance claim in court, because the work was not authorised in the first place.

Related guides

Read the judgment: Louis v Sadiq, Court of Appeal, 12 November 1996 (vLex)

Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.

Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free

Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.

We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.