PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Power v Shah: why there is no party wall award without a notice

Power & Kyson v Shah [2023] EWCA Civ 239 is the Court of Appeal decision that settled a long argument among party wall surveyors: if the building owner never served a notice, the neighbour cannot start the Act's surveyor process on their own. An award made in those circumstances is void. The neighbour is not left without help, but their route is the ordinary civil courts, not a party wall award.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

What happened

Mr Shah carried out work to his house in Bull Lane, Dagenham. His planning consultant told him the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 did not apply, so he served no party structure notice under section 3, before or after the work.

The neighbours at number 36 believed the work included removing a chimney breast from the party wall and that it had damaged their home. They appointed a surveyor, Mr Kyson. When Mr Shah did not engage, Mr Kyson used the default power in section 10(4) to appoint a second surveyor, Mr Power, on Mr Shah's behalf.

In July 2018 the two surveyors made an award. It found that notice should have been served, that the work had caused damage, and that Mr Shah should pay £4,223.49 plus VAT in compensation and £4,630 in surveyors' fees. Mr Shah challenged it. The High Court ([2022] EWHC 209 (QB)) held the award invalid, and the surveyors appealed.

Whether the chimney breast was removed, or the damage real, was never decided. The case was only about the surveyors' power.

The question for the court

Can an adjoining owner use the section 10 dispute procedure when the building owner served no notice and says the Act does not apply?

What the Court of Appeal decided

The court said no, unanimously. Lord Justice Coulson gave the main judgment, with Lord Justice Lewison and Lady Justice Elisabeth Laing agreeing.

  • The rights in section 2(2), including cutting away a chimney breast under section 2(2)(g), can only be used after a notice under section 3. The notice is mandatory.
  • The section 10 procedure only comes into play once a notice has been served. A deemed dispute under section 5 needs a notice, and the court saw no reason why a real dispute should be treated differently.
  • The scheme exists so that proposed work is open and agreed in advance. It was not built to sort out arguments about work already finished.
  • Nothing in the Act lets an adjoining owner trigger section 10 by themselves.
  • The neighbour keeps their common law rights: trespass, nuisance, negligence and an injunction.

Lord Justice Lewison put it in four words: "no party structure notice, no Act". The award was therefore a nullity, and so was the fee element.

Why it matters in practice

Before 2023, some surveyors routinely acted for neighbours whose building owner had ignored the Act, appointing a surveyor "for" the silent owner and making an award. Power v Shah stops that practice for party structure work. Awards made that way can be ignored or set aside, and the surveyors' fees fall with them.

For neighbours, the case is a warning against assuming a party wall surveyor can fix everything after the event. If your neighbour built without notice, your claim for damage is a civil claim. That means evidence, possibly a solicitor, and the court's costs rules. It does not mean you have no claim. Older cases such as Roadrunner v Dean and Louis v Sadiq show courts treating a builder who ignored the Act firmly.

For building owners, the case is not a loophole. Skipping notice removes the Act's protection and leaves you open to an injunction and to damages in nuisance or trespass.

What to do differently

If you are the neighbour and work has started without notice: 1. Write to the building owner straight away, saying the work appears to need notice and asking them to stop and serve one. 2. Photograph and date everything, including existing cracks. 3. If they serve a notice, even late, the Act's process can then run and a surveyor can deal with the work from that point. 4. If they refuse, take advice on an injunction quickly. Delay makes an injunction harder to get.

If you are the building owner: serve the right notice before work starts. If you have already started, serve a notice now. The judgment confirms the scheme works on notices, so a late notice is better than none.

Frequently asked questions

Does Power v Shah apply to excavation under section 6?

The case was about party structure work under sections 2 and 3. The reasoning, that the Act's procedure starts with the building owner's notice, applies naturally to section 6 notices too, and surveyors generally read it that way. The court did not have to rule on a section 6 case, so take advice if your facts are unusual.

Can my neighbour's surveyor still make an award if I never got a notice?

Not for the past work. Without a notice there is no dispute under the Act, so surveyors appointed by a neighbour alone have no power to award compensation or fees. If a notice is later served, surveyors can deal with the work it covers from then on.

Does this mean a building owner who ignores the Act gets away with it?

No. The neighbour can sue in trespass, nuisance or negligence and can seek an injunction. The building owner also loses the Act's statutory right to do the work, which is what normally protects them from a trespass claim.

Can an adjoining owner serve the notice themselves?

No. Only the building owner, the person proposing the work, can serve a notice under the Act. The court said nothing in the Act lets the adjoining owner start the process.

What happened to the surveyors' fees in Power v Shah?

They went with the award. Because the award was void, the £4,630 fee direction had no effect either. That is a practical risk for any surveyor who acts without a valid notice.

Related guides

Read the judgment: Power & Anor v Shah [2023] EWCA Civ 239 (National Archives)

Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.

Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free

Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.

We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.