PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Roadrunner v Dean: causation when the builder ignored the Act

Roadrunner Properties Ltd v Dean [2003] EWCA Civ 1816 is the Court of Appeal case on proving damage when a neighbour did party wall work without serving notice. The court said a building owner who ignores the Act should not gain a "forensic advantage" from the missing evidence a notice and schedule of condition would have produced. Judges should take a reasonably robust approach to causation. The neighbour recovered for the damage you would expect from the work, but not for unrelated defects.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

What happened

Roadrunner held a long lease of a house in Molasses Row, Battersea. Next door, the owner had contractors cut a chase into the party wall at first-floor level for radiator pipes. They used a Kango heavy hammer drill, which a witness said was wholly unsuitable for that job. No party structure notice was served under section 3.

Soon afterwards, a surveyor acting for Roadrunner's prospective subtenant found damage in the conservatory: lifted floor tiles, a loose skirting board and cracked walls. Roadrunner later added claims for paving, roof gullies, glazing, lead flashing and an external crack.

The trial judge dismissed the claim, finding causation not proved. Roadrunner appealed.

The question for the court

Was the damage caused by the chasing work? And where the builder skipped notice, so there was no record of the neighbour's property beforehand, how should a court approach that question?

What the Court of Appeal decided

Lord Justice Chadwick gave the main judgment, with Lord Justice Sedley agreeing.

  • The work was cutting into a party structure under section 2(2)(f). That right is subject to making good damage under section 2(5), and section 7(2) requires compensation for loss or damage caused by the work.
  • With no notice, the claim ran in nuisance and negligence. Causation was the same either way.
  • The trial judge was wrong to treat the timing of the damage as irrelevant. Damage appearing straight after work that would be expected to cause it can support an inference that the work caused it.
  • A building owner who ignores the notice scheme should not benefit from the lack of evidence that results. Courts should be slow to accept after-the-event theories offered to explain damage away.

Sedley LJ added that whether timing matters depends on the work. It means little after wallpapering and a great deal after heavy percussive drilling.

The appeal was allowed for the conservatory floor tiles and the cracks in the conservatory, kitchen and bedroom walls. There was no evidence linking the paving or other items to the work, so those failed. Damages were agreed at £1,740. A claim of £4,620 for management time was not allowed.

Why it matters in practice

The case cuts both ways, and that is what makes it useful.

For neighbours, it means you are not sunk just because nobody made a schedule of condition. If the damage appears soon after the work and is the kind that work would cause, a court can infer the link, and the builder who skipped notice will struggle to argue otherwise.

But it is not a blank cheque. Each item of damage has to be connected to the work. Roadrunner lost on everything that had no obvious link to drilling a chase. Bundling every defect in the house into one claim weakens the strong parts.

For building owners, this is one of the clearest reasons to serve notice. A schedule of condition taken before work protects you as much as the neighbour, because it records cracks that were already there.

The court also criticised the use of two competing experts on a modest claim where a single joint expert would have done. Costs in small damage claims can quickly dwarf the damage.

What to do differently

If you are the neighbour: 1. Photograph and date damage as soon as you notice it, and write down when the work happened. 2. Separate damage that matches the work (cracks near the wall, things shaken loose) from older or unrelated defects. 3. Consider proposing a single joint expert to keep costs proportionate.

If you are the building owner: serve notice and get a schedule of condition before any cutting, drilling or chasing into a party wall. Use tools suited to the job. A heavy breaker on a party wall is an invitation to a claim.

Frequently asked questions

Can I claim for party wall damage if no notice was served?

Yes. Without a notice the Act's surveyor process is not available (see Power v Shah), but you can claim in nuisance or negligence through the courts. Roadrunner v Dean shows courts will take a firm approach to causation against a builder who ignored the Act.

Does the timing of the damage prove it was caused by the work?

Not by itself, but it can be strong evidence. The court said timing supports an inference where the damage is what you would expect from that kind of work. Heavy drilling followed by cracking is persuasive; light work followed by unrelated defects is not.

Why was the damages figure so small?

Because only the damage linked to the drilling was proved, and that was modest: £1,740 for floor tiles and wall cracks. The other items had no evidence connecting them to the work, and management time was not recoverable as damages.

Is a schedule of condition legally required?

No. The Act does not require one, but surveyors almost always prepare one. Roadrunner shows why: without it, both sides are left arguing about what was there before.

Related guides

Read the judgment: Roadrunner Properties Ltd v Dean [2003] EWCA Civ 1816 (National Archives)

Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.

Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free

Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.

We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.