Rashid v Sharif: the garden wall that was a party fence wall
Rashid v Sharif [2014] EWCA Civ 377 is a Court of Appeal case about a garden shed in Ilford built on the remains of an old brick boundary wall. The trial judge decided the wall belonged entirely to one side and ordered the shed wall removed. The Court of Appeal found the wall actually straddled the boundary, making it a party fence wall. Demolishing and rebuilding it without following the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 was still a trespass, but a modest one, so the removal order was replaced with £300 damages and each side paid its own costs.
What happened
The back gardens of a house in Rutland Road and a house in Dudley Road, Ilford, met at the boundary. A wooden fence once divided them. A former owner of the Rutland Road house replaced it with a low brick wall about 225 mm thick.
The claimants bought the Rutland Road house in 1991. The defendants bought the Dudley Road house in 2009. That summer their builder knocked down most of the old wall and put up a breeze-block shed, with its north wall built on what was left of the old one. The claimants objected and the defendants refused to move the shed.
At trial the district judge found the old wall stood on the claimants' land, so the shed was a trespass. She ordered the shed's rear wall removed and the old wall rebuilt. As a fallback she found the claimants had acquired the strip by adverse possession.
The question for the court
Who owned the old brick wall and the land under it? Had the defendants trespassed, and if so what was the right remedy?
What the Court of Appeal decided
Lord Justice Jackson gave the main judgment, with Lord Justice Elias agreeing.
- Ownership: The former owner's evidence was that he built the wall along the line of the old fence. It did not show he built it wholly on his own land. The court held the wall "was not built entirely" on his land. It sat partly in each garden.
- Party fence wall: A wall standing astride the boundary that is not part of a building is a party fence wall under the Act's definitions in section 20. Adverse possession could not apply to it.
- Trespass: The defendants demolished it and built a new wall without serving notices or following the Act. That was a trespass, though less serious than the trial judge thought.
- Remedy: The mandatory injunction could not stand. The claimants' own shed and wall blocked their access to the affected area, so the practical harm was small. Damages of £300 were awarded in place of an injunction.
- Costs: No order on the claim, counterclaim or appeal. Each side bore its own costs of the whole case.
Why it matters in practice
Garden walls can be party walls. Many people assume the Act only covers walls between houses. A masonry wall standing across the boundary, even a low garden wall, is a party fence wall. Section 2 gives rights to work on it, including demolishing and rebuilding, but only after notice under section 3.
Ownership is often not what you think. The trial judge got the boundary wrong. Deeds and plans rarely show where a garden wall sits to the centimetre. Before demolishing or building on a boundary wall, find out whether it is on your land, theirs, or both.
Small trespasses lead to small awards. The defendants were in the wrong, but the court looked at what the claimants actually lost. Litigating a dispute like this to the Court of Appeal is costly, and the final order left everyone paying their own lawyers.
Timber fences are different: they are not party fence walls, and the Act does not cover them.
What to do differently
If you want to replace or build on a shared garden wall: 1. Check whether it is masonry and whether it straddles the boundary. 2. If it does, serve a party structure notice under section 3 before touching it. 3. If you want to build a new wall on the boundary line instead, that is a line of junction notice under section 1.
If your neighbour has already done it: 1. Write promptly setting out your objection. 2. Consider what you have really lost before going to court. Rashid v Sharif shows a court may give modest damages rather than order removal. 3. Try mediation first.
Frequently asked questions
Is a garden wall a party wall?
It can be. A masonry wall that stands across the boundary and is not part of a building is a "party fence wall" under section 20 of the Act. Work to it is notifiable. A wall wholly on one side, or a timber fence, is not a party fence wall.
Can I knock down a shared garden wall and rebuild it?
Section 2 gives a building owner the right to demolish and rebuild a party fence wall, but only after serving notice under section 3 and following the Act's procedure. Doing it without notice is a trespass, as Rashid v Sharif shows.
Why was the shed not removed?
Because the trespass was limited and the claimants could not even reach the affected strip, which was behind their own shed. The court decided £300 damages was the proportionate remedy instead of ordering demolition.
What is adverse possession and why did it not apply?
Adverse possession lets someone gain title to land by occupying it for long enough as if they owned it. It did not apply because the wall sat on both properties and was shared, rather than land exclusively occupied by one side.
Related guides
- Garden walls and boundary fences: when the Act applies
- What if the boundary runs down the middle of the garden wall?
- Garden rooms and outbuildings: party wall rules
- Can my neighbour make me pay half of a new boundary wall?
- Section 1: new walls on the line of junction
- All party wall court cases
Read the judgment: Rashid & Anor v Sharif & Anor [2014] EWCA Civ 377 (National Archives)
Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.
Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free
Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.
We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.