PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Reeves v Blake: what legal costs a party wall award can include

Reeves v Blake [2009] EWCA Civ 611 (sometimes cited as Blake v Reeves) is the Court of Appeal ruling that party wall surveyors cannot order one owner to pay the other's legal costs of preparing an injunction. Surveyors can award reasonable costs connected with the Act's own dispute process under section 10(13). Court proceedings, even ones that were only threatened, are outside that.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

What happened

Ms Blake planned to demolish 1 Farlow Road in Wandsworth and build a new block with a basement. The excavation was close to the garage driveway of her neighbour, Ms Reeves.

The surveyors' first award found Ms Blake's first notice invalid but upheld her second one. Ms Blake then began foundation work that Ms Reeves said was not yet authorised. Ms Reeves's solicitors prepared papers for a High Court injunction. Before anything was issued, Ms Blake gave undertakings to stop, so no court case was ever started.

A later award directed Ms Blake to pay Ms Reeves's legal costs of £7,651.49 plus VAT, covering the injunction preparation. Ms Blake appealed. Wandsworth County Court deleted that part of the award, and Ms Reeves took it to the Court of Appeal.

The question for the court

Can surveyors appointed under section 10 make one owner pay the cost of advice and preparation for injunction proceedings that were contemplated but never issued? Ms Reeves relied on two parts of section 10: subsection (12)(c), which lets an award decide "any other matter arising out of or incidental to the dispute", and subsection (13)(c), which covers reasonable costs of other matters arising out of the dispute.

What the Court of Appeal decided

No. Lord Justice Etherton gave the main judgment, with Lords Justices Mummery and Moses agreeing.

  • Surveyors can order one owner to pay the other's reasonable costs, but only costs connected with the statutory dispute process.
  • An injunction for trespass or nuisance is a court remedy outside the Act. Surveyors have no power to grant it, so the costs of seeking it are not costs "arising out of the dispute" in the Act's sense.
  • The Act's purpose points the same way. Etherton LJ described it as a mechanism for dispute resolution "which avoids recourse to the Courts". It would be odd for surveyors to price up litigation the scheme is designed to avoid.

The appeal was dismissed. The direction to pay £7,651.49 plus VAT stayed deleted.

Why it matters in practice

This case draws a firm line around what a party wall award can do about money.

Inside the line: the surveyors' own fees, the cost of making the award, checking the work, and other reasonable costs of the party wall process itself. These are the costs section 10(13) is about.

Outside the line: solicitors' and barristers' costs of going to court, or getting ready to, for trespass, nuisance or an injunction. If you want those, you need a court order. Courts decide costs under their own rules, which usually means the losing side pays a large part of the winner's costs, but not always all of them.

The line can be fine. In Ahmed v Parsons (2018), covered on our party wall cases hub, a Cardiff judge accepted a small barrister's fee within an award where it arose from the statutory dispute itself. The distinction is what the cost was for.

What to do differently

If you are the neighbour and work starts without authority: 1. Instruct a solicitor if you need an injunction, but understand those costs will be recovered, if at all, through the court, not through the award. 2. Ask your solicitor to deal with costs in any undertaking the building owner gives. In Reeves v Blake the undertakings stopped the work but did not deal with who paid for getting there. 3. Keep your surveyor's work and your solicitor's work separate, with separate invoices, so it is clear which costs fall under the award.

If you are the building owner: do not start work an award has not yet covered. Doing so invites an injunction, and while surveyors cannot make you pay for it, a court can.

Frequently asked questions

Can a party wall surveyor award legal costs?

Yes, in part. Surveyors can award reasonable costs connected with the statutory process under section 10(13), which can include some legal advice on the party wall dispute itself. They cannot award costs of court proceedings, or of preparing for them, which Reeves v Blake held fall outside the Act.

If my neighbour had to threaten an injunction, who pays?

If the injunction is never issued, recovering those costs is hard. Surveyors cannot award them, and without a court case there is no court costs order. The best route is to agree costs as part of any undertaking or settlement the building owner gives.

Is Reeves v Blake the same case as Blake v Reeves?

Yes. Different reports list the parties in different orders. The neutral citation, [2009] EWCA Civ 611, identifies it either way. The Court of Appeal later relied on it in Power v Shah.

Does the building owner always pay the surveyors' fees?

Usually, because the work is for the building owner's benefit. Section 10(13) lets the surveyors decide who pays, so in some cases, for example where the neighbour's demands cause unreasonable extra work, part of the cost can be put on the neighbour.

Related guides

Read the judgment: Reeves v Blake [2009] EWCA Civ 611 (National Archives)

Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.

Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free

Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.

We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.