Seeff v Ho: when a neighbour's spoken consent runs out
Seeff v Ho [2011] EWCA Civ 186 is a Court of Appeal case about a garage conversion in Edgware where the only "agreement" was a conversation over the garden fence. The court held that the neighbour's spoken consent was conditional on the work following the proper procedures and the planning permission. When the roof was built higher and differently, and fixings went into his wall, that went beyond his consent and was a trespass. Damages rose from £200 to £500, and neither side recovered its costs.
What happened
The Seeffs and the Hos lived next door to each other in Edgware, with garages built against each other. In 2006 the Hos planned to turn the garage next to the Seeffs into a study and raise its roof.
Over the garden fence, Mr Seeff gave oral consent. The judge found he said, in effect, go as high as you like but do not cover my window. Planning permission was granted for a hipped roof at the existing height. No Party Wall Act notices were served.
In 2007, during the work, brackets were drilled into the Seeffs' side wall. The Seeffs objected in writing. The Hos went on to build a gable-end roof about 12 inches higher than approved, without planning consent for it.
The Seeffs sued. The county court found a trespass and awarded £200, with a costs order against the Seeffs. Both sides appealed.
The questions for the court
Did the work trespass, given the oral consent? Was a party wall notice needed? What remedy and damages were right? Who should bear the costs?
What the Court of Appeal decided
Lord Justice Thomas gave the main judgment, with Lords Justices Etherton and Maurice Kay agreeing.
- Consent: The consent was conditional on the work being done properly, including in line with the planning permission. Building something different went outside it, so the work trespassed.
- The Party Wall Act: The court did not need to decide whether notice was required, though it thought the trial judge was probably right that it was.
- Remedy: Ordering the roof taken down would be oppressive and out of proportion, so there was no injunction.
- Damages: Increased from £200 to £500 to reflect the further trespass. There was no evidence that the Seeffs' house had lost value.
- Costs: The earlier costs order was set aside, and the court made no order as to costs, given that the Seeffs had failed on their larger damages claims.
Why it matters in practice
Seeff v Ho is a cautionary tale for both neighbours.
For the building owner, a friendly chat is not a party wall agreement. It does not record what was agreed, it is easily misremembered, and it falls away if the work changes. Serving proper notice under section 3 would have fixed the scope in writing and given both sides the Act's protection.
For the neighbour, a trespass that is real but small will usually lead to small damages, not demolition. Courts weigh the harm against the cost and disruption of removal. Pursuing large damages that cannot be proved can leave you with no costs recovery even when you win on liability.
The broader pattern, seen again in later cases such as Rashid v Sharif and a 2022 East Dulwich loft case on our hub, is that neighbour disputes over modest encroachments can cost far more to litigate than the encroachment is worth.
What to do differently
If you are planning work: 1. Serve a written notice even if your neighbour says "go ahead". Their written consent in reply is then tied to a specific description of the work. 2. If plans change, tell them and serve a fresh or amended notice. 3. Stick to what planning permission allows, or get it varied first.
If you are the neighbour and said yes informally: 1. Put your understanding in writing straight away: what you agreed, and any conditions. 2. Object in writing as soon as the work departs from it, as the Seeffs did. 3. Before suing, get advice on what a court is realistically likely to award, and try mediation.
Frequently asked questions
Is verbal consent valid under the Party Wall Act?
The Act works on written notices, and its consent provisions assume consent is given in writing. Seeff v Ho shows the wider danger: even where a spoken agreement exists, the court will read it as limited to what was discussed and conditional on proper process. Get it in writing.
Will a court order my neighbour's extension to be removed?
Sometimes, but not usually for a minor trespass. In Seeff v Ho removal was called oppressive and disproportionate. Courts are more willing where the owner deliberately ignored the neighbour's rights and the harm is serious.
Why did the Seeffs get only £500?
Because the trespass was limited and there was no evidence that their home was worth less. Damages reflect the actual harm. The increase from £200 recognised that the trespass went further than the trial judge had found.
What does "no order as to costs" mean?
Each side pays its own legal costs. In neighbour disputes this can mean the winner still ends up seriously out of pocket, because legal costs often run far above any damages.
Related guides
- Neighbour text message consent: is it legally binding?
- Party wall notice consent vs acknowledgement
- What happens if a neighbour signs a notice but then objects
- Party wall rules for home extensions
- Section 3 party structure notices
- All party wall court cases
Read the judgment: Seeff v Ho & Anor [2011] EWCA Civ 186 (National Archives)
Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.
Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free
Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.
We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.