Taylor v Jones: who pays when the neighbour's building was already defective
Taylor v Jones and Taylor v Spriggs [2024] EWCA Civ 170 is the Court of Appeal's leading recent decision on what compensation under section 7(2) of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 covers when the neighbour's building already had hidden defects. The court held that the building owner pays to repair the damage the works caused, applying normal common law damages rules, but not to cure defects that were there before. The case went back to the county court to work out the figures.
What happened
Mr Taylor owned a lower ground floor flat with a garden in St George's Terrace, north-west London. He excavated the garden about 2.5 metres to build an extension, which needed underpinning along the rear wall of a mews building behind, at 5 and 6 St George's Mews.
Nobody knew that the mews building already had serious defects. A large horizontal crack at damp-proof course level left the rear wall effectively unsupported by its foundations, spanning like an arch. There were also extensive voids under the floor slabs and internal walls.
Experts agreed the works moved the rear wall by about 2 mm. That small movement caused internal walls and floor slabs to drop by up to 40 mm.
The third surveyor awarded about £215,316 to the leaseholders of number 5 and about £165,874 to the freeholder, treating Mr Taylor as responsible for all of it. The county court reduced those to about £166,374 and £135,086. Mr Taylor appealed again.
The question for the court
Under section 7(2), must the building owner pay for underpinning the rear wall and filling the voids, when that work fixes defects his excavation did not cause?
What the Court of Appeal decided
Lord Justice Nugee gave the main judgment, with Lady Justice Macur and Lord Justice Bean agreeing.
- The measure of compensation: Section 7(2) requires compensation for "any loss or damage which may result" from the work. That is assessed on ordinary common law damages principles.
- Damage caused: Mr Taylor must pay to repair the internal walls and floor slabs, because his works damaged them.
- Pre-existing defects: Underpinning the rear wall was needed to cure a defect that was already there, not to repair what the works did. He was not liable for it. Filling voids under the slab that had not been damaged was treated the same way.
- Betterment: The court considered whether the neighbours would be better off. It found they had no real choice about underpinning and that Mr Taylor had not shown it would save them money later.
- Costs: His separate appeal on costs failed.
The case was sent back to the county court to decide how much of the repair cost related to the work he was not liable for. The court invited the parties to agree the figures.
Why it matters in practice
Compensation is about cause, not condition. Taylor v Jones confirms that a building owner is not the neighbour's insurer for every defect revealed by the work. You pay for the harm you cause, not for putting right what was wrong before.
But you still take the neighbour's building as you find it. The defects made the building more vulnerable, and Mr Taylor still had to pay for the damage his works caused to it, even though a sound building might not have moved as much.
The schedule of condition and investigation matter. The defects here were hidden. Where possible, a thorough pre-work survey, including trial pits on deep projects, gives both sides a record of what was there before.
Surveyors must separate the two. The third surveyor's awards treated everything as caused by the works. The Court of Appeal's approach requires surveyors to split repair costs into what flows from the damage and what cures existing defects.
What to do differently
If you are the building owner on a deep excavation: 1. Ask your engineer whether investigations of the neighbour's foundations are sensible before work starts. 2. Make sure the schedule of condition is detailed, with photographs. 3. If damage occurs, ask your surveyor to separate repair of damage from improvement or correction of existing defects.
If you are the neighbour: 1. Expect a claim to be scrutinised for pre-existing problems. 2. Get an engineer's view on which repairs are needed because of the works and which would have been needed anyway.
Frequently asked questions
Does the building owner have to pay for all the repairs if my house was already defective?
No. Under Taylor v Jones, they pay to repair the damage their works caused. Work needed to fix defects that already existed, such as underpinning a wall that was already unsupported, is not their liability, unless it is part of repairing the damage itself.
What is betterment in a party wall claim?
Betterment is where repairs leave the neighbour better off than before the damage. The court considered it here but found the neighbours had no real choice about the underpinning, and no saving had been shown, so it made no betterment deduction from what was otherwise payable.
Is section 7(2) compensation the same as damages in court?
The Court of Appeal said it is assessed on common law damages principles. That means compensation for the loss actually caused, putting the neighbour back in the position they would have been in, not a better one.
Who decides how much is caused by the works?
Initially the surveyors, through the award. If an owner appeals within 14 days under section 10(17), the county court decides. In Taylor v Jones the figures went back to the county court after the Court of Appeal set the principle.
Related guides
- Damage caused by party wall works: how to claim compensation
- Who pays for damage to a neighbour's property during building
- Excavations and underpinning: party wall rules explained
- Neighbour has shallow foundations and you are digging deeper
- The checklist for a professional schedule of condition
- All party wall court cases
Read the judgment: Taylor v Jones & Anor; Taylor v Spriggs [2024] EWCA Civ 170 (National Archives)
Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.
Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free
Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.
We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.