Dillard v F&C: Deed Stripped Surveyors of Compensation Power
The owner of a Georgian house in Soho signed a deed with the developer of the buildings next door, covering condition schedules, repairs, an indemnity and protection of his air handling unit. Disputes under those clauses were to go to a single expert. Party wall surveyors later made an addendum award of £9,350 in compensation, while the owner said his losses exceeded £500,000.
What happened
The owner of 23 Great Pulteney Street, a large Georgian house in Soho, signed a deed in October 2007 with the company planning to redevelop 24 to 27 Great Pulteney Street next door. The deed covered schedules of condition, a duty to make good damage, an indemnity for losses from the works, and protection or replacement of his air handling unit. Disputes under those clauses were to go to a single expert, whose decision would be final save for manifest error. A separate clause said the parties would adhere to the requirements of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996.
The developer served party wall notices in 2009 and 2010, and three awards followed. In April 2013 the surveyors made an addendum award dealing with compensation for the first time, fixing it at £9,350. The owner said his losses would exceed £500,000. He appealed, arguing among other things that the surveyors had no power to decide compensation because the deed sent it to an expert. The county court struck out those grounds.
What was decided
Mr Justice Akenhead allowed the appeal on 16 April 2014 and set the county court decision aside. He held that:
- The words "any dispute" in the damage and plant clauses were emphatic and all-embracing, so those disputes went exclusively to the expert.
- The promise to adhere to the Act's requirements meant matters like serving notices, not handing compensation to the surveyors.
- Running two parallel procedures would be unworkable, and parties are free to contract out of the Act in part.
- A challenge saying surveyors had no jurisdiction at all is not barred as an appeal from an appeal.
The judge urged the parties to agree a single route for resolving what was actually owed.
Why it matters for homeowners
Under section 10 of the Act, surveyors can resolve disputes connected with notifiable work, including compensation under section 7(2). But this case shows that a private deed signed with a developer can take damage claims out of the surveyors' hands. If you have signed such an agreement, an award on compensation may be invalid, and the route to recovery is the one in the deed.
What to do if this happens to you
- Read any neighbour or developer agreement for dispute clauses before works begin, and take legal advice on large projects.
- Decide deliberately whether damage claims should go to the surveyors or to an expert, and make the deed say so clearly.
- Our guide to party wall notices, awards and agreements explains how these documents fit together.
- See also how to claim compensation for party wall damage and Party Wall Act requirements for commercial developments.
The lesson: A private deed with a developer can replace the surveyors' role on compensation, so read its dispute clause before relying on an award.
Source
National Archives Find Case Law ([2014] EWHC 1219 (QB))
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More notices and awards stories
Serving Notice on a Council-Owned House: Newham Delay
A homeowner in Newham planning an extension needed to serve a party wall notice on the house next door, which the council owns and lets to a tenant. He asked the council repeatedly for the right contact details, and said its failure to reply held up his…
Ombudsman: Party Wall Agreement Breaches Are for the Courts
A resident in Bristol complained to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman that her neighbour had damaged her wall in breach of a party wall agreement meant to protect her building. The Ombudsman declined to investigate. It said the Party Wall Act…
Takhar v Mohamed: Settlement Took Dispute Outside the Act
A basement at a house in Chigwell led to several county court claims between neighbours, which were settled in 2016 by a Tomlin order. The settlement appointed an "Agreed Surveyor" to decide compensation as if under the Act. That surveyor later awarded the…
Power v Shah: No Party Structure Notice, No Party Wall Award
In Power v Shah the Court of Appeal decided that surveyors cannot make a valid award under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 when the building owner never served a notice for the work. The case concerned works at a house in Bull Lane, Dagenham, including the…
All notices and awards stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.