PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Takhar v Mohamed: Settlement Took Dispute Outside the Act

A basement at a house in Chigwell led to several county court claims between neighbours, which were settled in 2016 by a Tomlin order. The settlement appointed an "Agreed Surveyor" to decide compensation as if under the Act. That surveyor later awarded the neighbours about £500,000, against roughly £1 million claimed, and the building owners appealed using the Act's appeal route.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

31 August 2023 · Court judgment · Chigwell, Essex · [2023] EWHC 2190 (KB)

What happened

The owners of a house on Manor Road, Chigwell, carried out basement works. They served notice under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 around 2015, and surveyors made an award in August 2015. Four county court claims followed between them and the neighbours next door.

Those claims were settled in 2016 by a Tomlin order. Its schedule appointed a privately chosen agreed surveyor to decide compensation as if he had been appointed under the Act, with any challenge to be treated as a section 10(17) appeal. In 2017 a county court judge accepted the neighbours' argument that the parties had contracted out of the Act.

In October 2020 the agreed surveyor decided the compensation claim. The neighbours had sought about £1 million and he awarded about £500,000. The building owners appealed under section 10(17). The neighbours then argued the county court had no jurisdiction. The county court held that the Act did not apply but the settlement allowed a full re-hearing covering both damage and amount.

What was decided

Mrs Justice Foster allowed the appeal on 31 August 2023. She held that:

  • The settlement excluded the Act for current and future disputes, so the agreed surveyor's decision was not a statutory award and no statutory appeal existed. Parties cannot create that jurisdiction by agreement.
  • The county court could still hear a contractual claim about whether the settlement had been breached.
  • The neighbours were estopped from now saying the Act applied, having argued the opposite earlier.
  • Any challenge was likely to be a review for errors of principle or unfairness, not a fresh hearing, and was limited to the amount of compensation.

Why it matters for homeowners

Section 10(17) gives either owner 14 days to appeal a party wall award to the county court, and the court can rehear the matter. Once neighbours replace the statutory scheme with their own agreement, that safety net may disappear. What remains is a narrower contractual challenge, which can be harder and more expensive to pursue. Positions taken in earlier litigation can also bind you later.

What to do if this happens to you

The lesson: Before signing a settlement of a party wall dispute, check whether it keeps or replaces the Act's procedure and appeal rights.

Source

National Archives Find Case Law ([2023] EWHC 2190 (KB))

Related guide: read our guide on this topic

More notices and awards stories

Serving Notice on a Council-Owned House: Newham Delay

20 November 2024 · Ombudsman decision · Newham, London · LGSCO 24 012 065

A homeowner in Newham planning an extension needed to serve a party wall notice on the house next door, which the council owns and lets to a tenant. He asked the council repeatedly for the right contact details, and said its failure to reply held up his…

Ombudsman: Party Wall Agreement Breaches Are for the Courts

3 September 2024 · Ombudsman decision · Bristol · LGSCO 24 006 364

A resident in Bristol complained to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman that her neighbour had damaged her wall in breach of a party wall agreement meant to protect her building. The Ombudsman declined to investigate. It said the Party Wall Act…

Power v Shah: No Party Structure Notice, No Party Wall Award

7 March 2023 · Court judgment · Dagenham, London · [2023] EWCA Civ 239

In Power v Shah the Court of Appeal decided that surveyors cannot make a valid award under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 when the building owner never served a notice for the work. The case concerned works at a house in Bull Lane, Dagenham, including the…

K Group v Saidco: Award 11 Years After Leak Set Aside

19 July 2021 · Court judgment · Aldford House, Park Lane, London · County Court at Central London, G20CL136

Between 2009 and 2013 two upper floors of Aldford House, a mansion block near Park Lane, were converted from two flats into four under a 2009 party wall award. A leak into a flat below in late 2009 was linked to the works, but no compensation award followed.…

All notices and awards stories · Latest party wall news

Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.