K Group v Saidco: Award 11 Years After Leak Set Aside
Between 2009 and 2013 two upper floors of Aldford House, a mansion block near Park Lane, were converted from two flats into four under a 2009 party wall award. A leak into a flat below in late 2009 was linked to the works, but no compensation award followed. In 2020, after the original developer had gone into liquidation, the adjoining owner's surveyor acting alone issued a fresh award against later owners, ordering substantial compensation and threatening removal of the new flats.
What happened
Between 2009 and 2013 the sixth and seventh floors of Aldford House, a block near Park Lane in London, were converted from two flats into four. The work was notifiable under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, and an award was made in July 2009. Late in 2009 a leak into flat 54 on the fifth floor was linked to the works. The surveyors corresponded about it until 2012, but no award on compensation was ever made, and in 2015 the building owner's surveyor considered himself incapable of acting.
By 2020 the original developer was in liquidation. That year the adjoining owner's surveyor, acting alone, made awards against later owners of the new flats. The November 2020 award ordered substantial compensation for the 2009 leak, required updated structural calculations and threatened removal of the new flats. Earlier 2020 awards had put compensation at £50,000. The later owners appealed on twelve grounds.
What was decided
On 19 July 2021, HHJ Parfitt in the County Court at Central London allowed the appeal on every ground and set the award aside as a nullity. Among the findings:
- The surveyor had no jurisdiction over the appellants, who were not the original building owner.
- No relevant dispute existed when the award was made. The 2009 dispute had been dealt with by the first award, and a new dispute would need surveyors appointed afresh under section 10(1).
- The surveyor had no power to act alone, because the building owner's surveyor had not been validly replaced.
- Making an award without the appellants knowing breached natural justice.
- Any compensation claim was subject to a six-year limitation period running from the damage in 2009, so it was time-barred.
- The surveyor had no power to order removal of the flats.
Why it matters for homeowners
Section 10 allows surveyors to settle disputes arising under the Act, and section 7(2) gives a right to compensation. But this decision indicates that a compensation claim follows the usual six-year limitation period from when the damage occurred, under section 9 of the Limitation Act 1980, not from when an award is eventually made. A surveyor cannot revive an old dispute single-handed, cannot bind new owners who were never party to it, and must give everyone a chance to be heard. It is a county court decision, so it is persuasive rather than binding.
What to do if this happens to you
- Report damage from party wall works promptly and ask the surveyors to make an award on it; do not let correspondence drift for years.
- Diary the six-year limit from the date damage first appeared.
- If you receive an award you were not consulted on, act within the 14-day appeal window. See how to challenge or appeal a party wall award.
- Read how to claim compensation for party wall damage and buying a home with an outstanding party wall dispute.
The lesson: Claim compensation for party wall damage promptly, because a court applied a six-year limit from when the damage happened.
Source
Falcon Chambers (with judgment transcript) (County Court at Central London, G20CL136)
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More notices and awards stories
Serving Notice on a Council-Owned House: Newham Delay
A homeowner in Newham planning an extension needed to serve a party wall notice on the house next door, which the council owns and lets to a tenant. He asked the council repeatedly for the right contact details, and said its failure to reply held up his…
Ombudsman: Party Wall Agreement Breaches Are for the Courts
A resident in Bristol complained to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman that her neighbour had damaged her wall in breach of a party wall agreement meant to protect her building. The Ombudsman declined to investigate. It said the Party Wall Act…
Takhar v Mohamed: Settlement Took Dispute Outside the Act
A basement at a house in Chigwell led to several county court claims between neighbours, which were settled in 2016 by a Tomlin order. The settlement appointed an "Agreed Surveyor" to decide compensation as if under the Act. That surveyor later awarded the…
Power v Shah: No Party Structure Notice, No Party Wall Award
In Power v Shah the Court of Appeal decided that surveyors cannot make a valid award under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 when the building owner never served a notice for the work. The case concerned works at a house in Bull Lane, Dagenham, including the…
All notices and awards stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.