Gray v Elite: Court Backs Surveyors' Underpinning Scheme
Two neighbours in a Knightsbridge mews fell out over a basement. One owner had already built a piled basement; the developer next door wanted to underpin the shared wall instead to keep more floor space. Reinforced concrete underpinning counted as "special foundations", which need the neighbour's written consent, so work stopped and the statutory process restarted. A third surveyor later approved a mass concrete scheme.
What happened
The owner of 7 Ennismore Mews in London SW7 built a basement in 2001 on contiguous piles. That avoided underpinning the party walls but cost him some floor area. In 2012 the company that owned number 9 served a party wall notice for its own basement and chose to underpin, which kept the full floor area.
The neighbour did not respond to the notice, so surveyors were appointed on his behalf and an award was made in August 2012. Once digging began, two problems emerged: some of the neighbour's piles had drifted towards the boundary, and the reinforced concrete underpinning amounted to special foundations. Under section 7(4) of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, special foundations need the adjoining owner's written consent. He refused, and work stopped in November 2012.
The process was restarted. In October 2014 the third surveyor made an award approving a mass concrete underpinning scheme, refused the neighbour compensation under section 11(11) and reduced the fees his own surveyor could recover. The neighbour went to court seeking to have the first award declared invalid, damages for trespass and nuisance, and injunctions.
What was decided
In the county court the neighbour recovered £1,320 for cracking and was found entitled in principle to a section 11(11) payment because the new underpinning used his piles. His challenge to the approved scheme failed, his surveyor's recoverable fees were limited to about a third, and he was ordered to pay 75% of the developer's costs.
On 3 November 2016 the Court of Appeal refused permission on the party wall grounds and dismissed the remaining appeal. Lord Justice Jackson held that section 7(1), which forbids causing unnecessary inconvenience, binds the building owner carrying out the works. It does not impose an absolute duty on surveyors when choosing a design, although they must have due regard to both owners. Both engineers had accepted the approved scheme was sound, so there was no basis to substitute the neighbour's preferred alternative. The fee reduction rested on a factual finding that most of the surveyor's work had been done on the client's instructions.
Why it matters for homeowners
- Reinforced concrete underpinning is likely to be treated as special foundations, which an adjoining owner can refuse under section 7(4).
- Once engineers agree a design is safe, appeals against a surveyor's technical choice under section 10(17) rarely succeed.
- Your own surveyor's fees are only recoverable from the building owner to the extent the work was properly part of the statutory process.
What to do if this happens to you
- If a notice mentions reinforced or steel-reinforced foundations, ask your surveyor whether they are special foundations before giving any written consent.
- Raise engineering objections early, backed by your own engineer's evidence, rather than after an award is made. Our guide to excavation and underpinning under the Party Wall Act explains the main options.
- Keep your surveyor focused on the statutory role, not on acting as your advocate, or you may end up paying much of the bill. See how party wall surveyor fees can be challenged.
- Read up on the third surveyor's role if the two surveyors cannot agree.
The lesson: If the engineers agree a scheme is sound, a court is unlikely to replace it with the neighbour's preferred alternative.
Source
National Archives Find Case Law ([2016] EWCA Civ 1318)
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More excavation and collapse stories
Kirupakaran v Ibrahim: £1.5m Party Wall Claim Struck Out
In June 2026 the Technology and Construction Court struck out a claim of about £1.5 million brought by the owner of a terraced building in Croydon Road, London SE20, after works next door damaged it. The neighbouring former pub was being extended and…
Neighbour Extension Collapsed Tenant's Decking: Clarion Pays
A Clarion Housing tenant's garden decking collapsed into the neighbouring garden in March 2023 while the neighbour was building a rear extension. The neighbour's works, which began in December 2022, had also blocked drains and destabilised her fence. A party…
Richmond Terraced Homes Collapse During Basement Works
Shortly before 3pm on 10 September 2024, two terraced houses on Lower Mortlake Road in Richmond collapsed while undergoing refurbishment. The roofs caved in and the upper and ground floors were badly damaged. The houses were part of a redevelopment into 14…
Hackney Rebuild Collapsed; 20 Evacuated From House Next Door
On 24 June 2023 the rear of a three-storey semi-detached house with a basement on Gloucester Drive, Hackney, collapsed from roof level to the ground. The house was being reconstructed and nobody lived there. London Fire Brigade said the collapse was believed…
All excavation and collapse stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.