Storm Felled Shared Boundary Wall: Insurer Pays 50% Share
A storm blew down a boundary wall jointly owned by a couple and their neighbour. Their home insurer, Tesco Underwriting, said joint ownership meant it could not carry out the repair itself and offered a cash settlement of £1,478.11. The couple refused: a structural engineer found the foundations needed replacing, which the insurer's surveyor had missed.
What happened
A couple's boundary wall, jointly owned with their neighbour, was blown over in a storm. They claimed on their home insurance with Tesco Underwriting Limited. Because the wall was jointly owned, the insurer said it could not carry out the repairs itself and would settle in cash at 50% of the cost. It offered £1,478.11.
The couple rejected that offer because it would not pay for rebuilding. They commissioned a structural engineer, who found that the wall's foundations needed to be replaced, something the insurer's surveyor had not identified. They also complained that the claim had been handled poorly.
What the Ombudsman decided
The Financial Ombudsman Service issued a provisional decision on 6 January 2025, which the couple accepted and the insurer did not contest. The final decision upheld the complaint and required the insurer to:
- pay a cash settlement of £5,312.16, being 50% of the lowest builder's quote of £11,824.32 including VAT, less the £600 excess;
- reimburse the cost of the structural engineer's report, with 8% simple interest if the couple had already paid it, or pay the invoice directly; and
- pay £300 in total for poor claim handling.
The decision did not involve the neighbour's insurer and did not discuss the Party Wall etc. Act 1996.
Why it matters for homeowners
Many garden boundary walls stand astride the line and are owned jointly, which makes them party fence walls under section 20 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. Insurers commonly treat their policyholder as owning only a share, so they may pay half and leave the other half to the neighbour or their insurer. Rebuilding a party fence wall is also notifiable work under section 2, so one owner should serve a party structure notice under section 3, unless both agree in writing. Under section 11 the cost of rebuilding a defective shared wall can be split according to each owner's use and responsibility.
What to do if this happens to you
- Tell your neighbour promptly and ask whether they will claim on their own insurance for their share.
- If your insurer's surveyor's scope looks too narrow, get an independent engineer's opinion; the cost may be recoverable.
- Agree who will organise the rebuild and confirm it in writing, serving a party structure notice if needed.
- Read whether home insurance covers party wall damage, who pays for a new boundary wall and when the Act covers garden walls.
The lesson: For a jointly owned wall, expect your insurer to pay only your share, and arrange the rest with your neighbour.
More insurance and housing stories
Tribunal: Leaseholder Need Not Pay Chimney Party Wall Fees
A freeholder of a converted house in Poole had a dangerous rear chimney removed after the council issued a demolition notice, then sought half the cost from the leaseholder of the other flat through the service charge. That included a £2,160 removal invoice…
Neighbour's Builders Damaged Tenant's Garden: £615 Award
A Southern Housing tenant reported in May 2023 that builders working on the privately owned house next door had damaged her side gate, removed part of her fence and blocked her garden access. An inspection also found a broken manhole cover and hard-standing…
Neighbour Extension Cracked Council Tenant's Home: Ombudsman
A council tenant in Epping Forest complained that his home next to a privately owned house had cracked when the neighbour built a rear extension. A survey commissioned by the council found a steel beam extending beyond the party wall line, raising a possible…
Truck Hit Shared Wall: Insurer Must Pay Half the Rebuild
A recovery truck towing a large vehicle struck a neighbour's garden wall, and the damage spread to a homeowner's front wall and to a shared party wall. Her home insurer, U K Insurance, argued the wall was already leaning, and its settlement offers fell from…
All insurance and housing stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.