Tribunal: Leaseholder Need Not Pay Chimney Party Wall Fees
A freeholder of a converted house in Poole had a dangerous rear chimney removed after the council issued a demolition notice, then sought half the cost from the leaseholder of the other flat through the service charge. That included a £2,160 removal invoice and £2,856 in engineering and party wall fees. A draft party wall agreement had been prepared but never signed.
What happened
A house on Park Lake Road in Poole had been divided into flats. The freeholder, who also had an interest as a lessee, arranged for a rear chimney to be removed after it was reported to the council and the council issued a demolition notice. A firm of surveyors and engineers prepared a draft party wall agreement, which was never signed; a later document from the same firm said the leaseholder of the other flat had altered it, making it void.
The freeholder then applied to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to decide whether the leaseholder had to pay, through the service charge, half of several major works costs. These included a £2,160 invoice for removing the chimney, a £2,856 invoice for engineering and party wall fees, and roof support linked to the chimney removal.
What was decided
In a decision dated 16 December 2025 the tribunal found:
- The chimney was dangerous and the freeholder had acted responsibly.
- However, the lease obliged the landlord to repair, maintain, redecorate and renew. Removing the chimney did not fall within those words, so the leaseholder was not liable for any of the removal cost.
- The engineering and party wall fees invoice did not contain enough detail, and the costs incurred as freeholder could not be separated from those incurred as a lessee, so they were not shown to be reasonably incurred. Nothing was payable.
- The related roof support work was tied to the chimney removal and also not recoverable.
The tribunal did not decide whether the draft party wall agreement had any legal effect. Other major works were found payable, totalling £3,622.50.
Why it matters for homeowners
In converted houses the walls and chimneys between flats, and between the building and next door, are often party structures. Work to a chimney attached to a party wall can be notifiable under section 2 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. Under the Act, the building owner usually pays for their own works and the reasonable costs of the adjoining owner's surveyor, under section 10(13). But when a landlord tries to pass those costs to leaseholders through the service charge, the lease terms and the reasonableness test under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 decide the outcome.
What to do if this happens to you
- If you are a leaseholder asked to pay for party wall or structural work, check your lease's repair and service charge clauses carefully.
- Ask for itemised invoices showing what each fee was for.
- You can apply to the First-tier Tribunal to decide whether a service charge is payable and reasonable.
- Read how party wall procedures apply to leaseholders and freeholders, party walls when the property is split into flats and chimney breast removal rules.
The lesson: Whether a leaseholder pays for party wall works depends on the lease wording and on clear, itemised invoices.
Source
First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) (HAV/00HQ/LSC/2024/0625)
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More insurance and housing stories
Neighbour's Builders Damaged Tenant's Garden: £615 Award
A Southern Housing tenant reported in May 2023 that builders working on the privately owned house next door had damaged her side gate, removed part of her fence and blocked her garden access. An inspection also found a broken manhole cover and hard-standing…
Storm Felled Shared Boundary Wall: Insurer Pays 50% Share
A storm blew down a boundary wall jointly owned by a couple and their neighbour. Their home insurer, Tesco Underwriting, said joint ownership meant it could not carry out the repair itself and offered a cash settlement of £1,478.11. The couple refused: a…
Neighbour Extension Cracked Council Tenant's Home: Ombudsman
A council tenant in Epping Forest complained that his home next to a privately owned house had cracked when the neighbour built a rear extension. A survey commissioned by the council found a steel beam extending beyond the party wall line, raising a possible…
Truck Hit Shared Wall: Insurer Must Pay Half the Rebuild
A recovery truck towing a large vehicle struck a neighbour's garden wall, and the damage spread to a homeowner's front wall and to a shared party wall. Her home insurer, U K Insurance, argued the wall was already leaning, and its settlement offers fell from…
All insurance and housing stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.