Lea Valley v Derbyshire: How Party Wall Damage Is Valued
A developer's excavation in Muswell Hill, carried out under a party wall award, damaged the adjoining house so badly that both sides accepted it would have to be demolished and rebuilt. Rebuilding was estimated at £1 million to £2 million, while the developer argued the loss in value was far lower.
What happened
A development company owned a freehold property in Muswell Hill, north London. The house next door was owned by an individual landlord and let as flats on assured shorthold tenancies. The developer's works included excavation notifiable under section 6 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, and an award was made in December 2014.
The award required the developer to make good any structural or decorative damage, or to pay money instead if the adjoining owner preferred, in an amount fixed by the agreed surveyor. The works did damage the neighbouring building. By around August 2016 the parties' advisers accepted in principle that it could not economically be repaired and would have to be demolished and rebuilt.
The figures were far apart. Demolition and rebuilding was estimated at roughly £1 million to £2 million. The developer's expert put the drop in the property's value at about £500,000 to £1 million. The developer asked the court to decide which measure applied.
What was decided
In a judgment of 16 June 2017, the Technology and Construction Court held:
- The award's making-good clause did not cover complete demolition and rebuilding, and it did not say how any payment should be calculated.
- Obiter, the judge thought such a clause might be beyond the surveyor's powers for section 6 work, because section 2 expressly mentions making good and section 6 does not.
- No earlier case had interpreted section 7(2). Taking it from first principles, compensation for loss or damage follows ordinary common law damages rules.
- Both reinstatement cost and diminution in value are possible measures. The aim is to put the owner back in the position they would have been in, and the result must be reasonable between the parties. A repair cost out of all proportion to the benefit may not be awarded.
The judge refused to make general declarations either way, because the answer depended on facts not yet established.
Why it matters for homeowners
Section 7(2) requires a building owner to compensate adjoining owners and occupiers for loss or damage caused by work under the Act. This case confirms that compensation is not automatically the full cost of repair. Where the repair bill is huge compared with the loss in value, a court may look at value instead. It also suggests that standard award wording about making good may not be enforceable for excavation work.
What to do if this happens to you
- Insist on a detailed schedule of condition before building starts, so damage can be proved later.
- If damage is serious, get evidence of both repair cost and the effect on value from qualified experts. Our guide to claiming compensation for party wall damage explains the process.
- Check what your award actually says about making good and payment in lieu, and see what evidence proves a damage claim.
The lesson: Compensation for party wall damage is assessed like ordinary damages, so a neighbour should evidence both repair costs and value loss.
Source
National Archives Find Case Law ([2017] EWHC 1353 (TCC))
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More cracks and compensation stories
Council Built Without Party Wall Agreement: Ombudsman View
A homeowner in Cornwall lived next to a council-owned property. The council started significant works on it without making sure a party wall agreement was in place, structural issues emerged during the works, and the homeowner complained that his home had…
Taylor v Jones: Who Pays for Pre-Existing Party Wall Defects
In Taylor v Jones the Court of Appeal ruled that a building owner does not have to pay, under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, for repairs to defects in a neighbour's property that existed before the works, even where the works revealed them or made repair…
Rodrigues v Sokal: Unappealed Party Wall Award Is Final
Two owners of a semi-detached pair in Manor Mount, Forest Hill, fell out when one began converting his half into four flats with a coach house. A party wall notice was served after some work had started. A surveyor's series of awards, the last in 2007, found…
All cracks and compensation stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.