Lords Push for Party Wall Act Review Withdrawn in 2025
During the Lords committee stage of the Planning and Infrastructure Bill on 15 September 2025, Baroness Hodgson of Abinger moved an amendment requiring a review of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, with a second amendment to stop developers interfering with a neighbour's structure without permission. She argued the Act is one-sided, predates the basement boom and has never had post-legislative scrutiny.
What happened
On 15 September 2025 the House of Lords debated the Planning and Infrastructure Bill at committee stage. Baroness Hodgson of Abinger, supported by Lord Jamieson, moved two amendments about party walls:
- Amendment 221 would have required the Secretary of State to review the Party Wall etc. Act 1996.
- Amendment 223 would have stopped developers interfering with the structural integrity of neighbouring homes without the owner's permission, which she linked to the rights to property and respect for the home in the European Convention on Human Rights.
Baroness Hodgson said she had herself received three party wall notices in three years. She argued that the Act is one-sided, that it was passed before basement digging became common and that in nearly 30 years it had never been reviewed or given post-legislative scrutiny. She referred to cases of unstable or collapsing houses, Lord Dubs's 2015 private member's bill on subterranean development, and a 2021 Newcastle University report counting 7,328 basement projects across 32 London boroughs between 2008 and 2019.
What the government said
Responding for the government, Baroness Taylor of Stevenage said she had no objection in principle to reviewing legislation, but successive governments since the late 1990s had regarded the Act as effective. She pointed out that the Act already requires a detailed party structure notice, and said structural safety is governed by the Building Regulations, notably Approved Document A, so changing the Act would not alter structural safety. She accepted things sometimes go wrong and offered continued discussion. Baroness Hodgson withdrew the review amendment, while disputing that the Act gives adjoining owners any way to object and stop work.
Why it matters for homeowners
The debate confirms there is no change to the law in prospect. The Act still works on the basis that a building owner may carry out notifiable work under sections 1, 2 and 6 after serving notice, and an adjoining owner who dissents gets a surveyor-led award under section 10 rather than a veto. Protection comes through the award's conditions, the duty not to cause unnecessary inconvenience in section 7(1), compensation under section 7(2) and security for expenses under section 12. Structural design is checked separately through building control.
What to do if this happens to you
- If you receive a notice for work you are worried about, dissent and appoint a surveyor so the award can impose protective conditions. Our guide explains what to do when you receive a party wall notice.
- For deep excavations, ask for security for expenses and a schedule of condition.
- Raise structural concerns with building control as well as through the party wall process. Read how the Party Wall Act, planning and building regulations differ.
The lesson: The Act is not being reviewed, so adjoining owners must rely on the award process rather than any right to block work.
More law and policy stories
RICS Consults on New Party Wall Guidance, 8th Edition (2026)
On 8 April 2026 the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors opened consultation on a draft 8th edition of its professional guidance, Party Wall Legislation and Procedure, which will replace the 7th edition. The consultation ran for about eight weeks over…
No New Law for Homes Damaged by Neighbour Works (2025)
On 14 January 2025 an MP asked whether the government would legislate to better protect homeowners whose homes are damaged by work on neighbouring buildings. Minister Alex Norris replied on 22 January that the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 already requires…
Government: No Date Set to Review the Party Wall Act (2024)
In October 2024 a peer asked whether the government would review the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, citing the balance of rights between developers and next-door neighbours and the spread of London basements. Housing minister Baroness Taylor of Stevenage replied…
All law and policy stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.