Udal v Dutton: Injunction Over Demolished Garden Wall
An elderly couple in Soudan Road, Battersea, shared a garden wall with the neighbours next door, who were building a rear extension and loft. A party wall award covered the loft and internal wall, but only recorded the garden wall in the schedule of condition. The neighbours' side then proposed demolishing and rebuilding the garden wall, citing an engineer's report that turned out to concern a different house, and part of it was knocked down before any addendum award was agreed.
What happened
An elderly couple owned 5 Soudan Road in Battersea, London SW11. Their neighbours at number 7 were developing their house, including a rear extension. The garden wall between the two properties was a party fence wall, owned jointly.
In June 2007 the couple's surveyor wrote that the neighbours would use the existing garden wall rather than demolish and rebuild it. A party wall award signed in October and November 2007 dealt with a loft conversion and the internal party wall. The garden wall appeared only in the schedule of condition, which recorded no sign that it was in poor or unstable condition.
On 19 November 2007 the neighbours' side said they now wanted to demolish and rebuild the garden wall, and a draft addendum award was prepared but not agreed. A note left on 25 November said builders might start on the wall within days and claimed it was bulging and unsafe, relying on an engineer's report that in fact related to number 15. On 26 November part of the wall was demolished without the couple's agreement.
What was decided
On 30 November 2007 His Honour Judge Coulson QC, in the Technology and Construction Court, granted an interim injunction. He found a serious issue to be tried, as the neighbours appeared to be trespassing and wrongfully interfering with the couple's property. The balance of convenience favoured protecting what was left of the wall, and damages would not be an adequate remedy. The order stopped further building or demolition work on the wall and required the neighbours to put up a hoarding or barrier without entering or damaging the couple's land. The judge criticised starting work before agreement was reached, saying preventing that is a purpose of the Act.
Why it matters for homeowners
A wall standing on the boundary between two gardens is a party fence wall under section 20 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. Demolishing and rebuilding it is notifiable work under section 2, needing a section 3 notice and either written consent or an award. An award that covers other works does not authorise works to the garden wall. A schedule of condition recording the wall as sound can also undermine later claims that it was dangerous.
What to do if this happens to you
- If a neighbour starts knocking down a shared wall without agreement, ask them in writing to stop at once and take photographs.
- Speak to your surveyor about whether the work is covered by any existing award, and to a solicitor about an urgent injunction if work continues.
- Read our guides on when the Party Wall Act covers garden walls, what happens if a neighbour ignores an award and when building work can be stopped.
The lesson: An award for one part of a project does not authorise other works, including demolishing a shared garden wall.
Source
National Archives Find Case Law ([2007] EWHC 2862 (TCC))
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More boundaries and shared walls stories
Collapsed Garden Party Wall Left 2.5 Years: Council Pays
A garden wall between two properties in Islington, one owned by the council, partly collapsed into the neighbouring garden in April 2022. The council knew by August that year the remainder was unsafe, pushed it over in October 2022 and then said rebuilding…
Neighbour's Canopy on Shared Garden Wall: Landlord at Fault
In 2020 a homeowner built a canopy on top of the garden wall shared with a housing association tenant's garden. The tenant said new coping stones sent water down the wall, waterlogging her garden and damaging the wall and patio, and that the canopy blocked…
Wellington v Grosvenor: Belgravia Wall Not a Party Wall
When the leaseholder of 39 Headfort Place in Belgravia bought the freehold from the Grosvenor estate in 1990, the transfer said walls and fences separating the property from adjoining properties were party walls. Years later the owner argued this made its…
All boundaries and shared walls stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.