Wellington v Grosvenor: Belgravia Wall Not a Party Wall
When the leaseholder of 39 Headfort Place in Belgravia bought the freehold from the Grosvenor estate in 1990, the transfer said walls and fences separating the property from adjoining properties were party walls. Years later the owner argued this made its south-east wall, which faces a communal garden and has windows and French doors, a party wall.
What happened
39 Headfort Place in Belgravia, London SW1, was held on a long lease from the Grosvenor estate. In 1990 the leaseholder used her right under the Leasehold Reform Act 1967 to buy the freehold. Clause 3(b) of the transfer said the walls and/or fences separating the property from adjoining properties were party walls, which Grosvenor said was a standard clause in its transfers.
The dispute concerned the house's south-east wall. It adjoins a communal garden rather than another building and contains windows, a bay window and French doors. It was agreed the wall lay wholly within the boundary of number 39 on the transfer plan. The later owner, Wellington Properties, argued that clause 3(b) made it a party wall. It was common ground that if that reading was right, the wall would be a party wall for the purposes of section 20 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996.
What was decided
The county court accepted Wellington's reading in December 2017. On 13 November 2018 Mr Justice Arnold allowed Grosvenor's appeal, describing the arguments as finely balanced. He held that "adjoining properties" meant adjoining buildings, so the clause did not make the garden wall a party wall. His reasons included:
- Wellington's reading conflicted with the parcels clause and the purpose of enfranchising the whole house.
- The clause referred to fences where there were none, showing loose drafting.
- Grosvenor's reading still gave the clause effect for the walls shared with the houses on Halkin Street.
- Wellington's reading would have made Grosvenor responsible for half the wall despite the lease putting repairs on the tenant, and could have allowed Grosvenor to block the windows.
Why it matters for homeowners
Section 20 of the Act defines a party wall by its physical position and use: a wall standing on the land of different owners, or one separating buildings in different ownership. Deeds can also declare walls to be party walls, but a court will read such wording in the context of the whole document and its practical consequences. Whether a wall is shared affects who must repair it, who can build on it and whether notice is needed.
What to do if this happens to you
- Check your title register, transfer and plan for any party wall declarations and boundary features.
- Do not rely on a single clause; consider what the wall separates and who has maintained it.
- Our guide what counts as a party wall or party structure explains the statutory definitions.
- See also when the boundary runs down the middle of a garden wall.
The lesson: A deed's party wall clause is read in context, so check the whole transfer and plan before assuming a wall is shared.
Source
National Archives Find Case Law ([2018] EWHC 3048 (Ch))
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More boundaries and shared walls stories
Collapsed Garden Party Wall Left 2.5 Years: Council Pays
A garden wall between two properties in Islington, one owned by the council, partly collapsed into the neighbouring garden in April 2022. The council knew by August that year the remainder was unsafe, pushed it over in October 2022 and then said rebuilding…
Neighbour's Canopy on Shared Garden Wall: Landlord at Fault
In 2020 a homeowner built a canopy on top of the garden wall shared with a housing association tenant's garden. The tenant said new coping stones sent water down the wall, waterlogging her garden and damaging the wall and patio, and that the canopy blocked…
Udal v Dutton: Injunction Over Demolished Garden Wall
An elderly couple in Soudan Road, Battersea, shared a garden wall with the neighbours next door, who were building a rear extension and loft. A party wall award covered the loft and internal wall, but only recorded the garden wall in the schedule of…
All boundaries and shared walls stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.