Windsor Loft Collapse Left Homeowner £200k Out of Pocket
On 6 August 2020, during a loft conversion on Springfield Road in Windsor, the roof had been removed when the brick gable wall collapsed into the work area. Three workers were seriously injured and the first floor of the occupied home was destroyed. Two days earlier the builder had told the homeowner the chimney breast would need propping, yet on the day he had supporting timbers and steels removed.
What happened
A builder was carrying out a loft conversion at an occupied house on Springfield Road, Windsor. Two days before the collapse, he told the homeowner that the chimney breast needed work and would have to be propped. On 6 August 2020, with the roof removed, he nonetheless directed workers to take out key supporting timbers and steels. The brick gable wall collapsed into the work area. Three workers were seriously injured and the first floor of the home was destroyed.
What the court decided
The builder pleaded guilty to breaching regulation 19(1) of the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015, which requires steps to stop structures collapsing during work. On 17 September 2025 at Reading Crown Court he was sentenced to 13 months in custody, suspended for two years, and ordered to pay £2,000 compensation to the homeowner.
The Health and Safety Executive said the homeowner faced a rebuild bill of about £200,000 because the builder's public liability insurance was invalid. An HSE inspector said the collapse was completely avoidable had the builder acted on his own findings about the unsupported chimney breast.
Why it matters for homeowners
Loft conversions frequently involve work covered by the Party Wall etc. Act 1996: cutting into a party wall to insert steel beams, raising it, or removing or altering a chimney breast attached to it. These are section 2 works needing a party structure notice under section 3. Where the wall is shared, a collapse can affect the neighbour as well as you. The Act makes the building owner liable to compensate neighbours under section 7(2), so if your builder is uninsured or their cover is invalid, the cost may fall on you. Surveyors can ask for proof of insurance and, under section 12, for security for expenses.
What to do if this happens to you
- Before signing, ask your builder for a current public liability insurance certificate and check the policy covers the type of work, including structural alterations.
- Ask for a structural engineer's design and temporary propping plan for steelwork and chimney removal.
- Check your own home insurance position for building works, and tell your insurer before work starts.
- Read our loft conversion party wall rules, chimney breast removal rules and whether home insurance covers party wall damage.
The lesson: Check your builder's public liability insurance is valid for structural work before a single support is removed.
More lofts and extensions stories
Neighbour Loft Conversion Damage: Council Not Liable (2026)
A homeowner in Bromley complained that the council failed to inspect a neighbour's loft conversion and ignored his requests for help after the works allegedly damaged his chimney and guttering and let water into his home. In June 2026 the Local Government and…
Fattahi v Charles Grosvenor: No Notice, No Builder Indemnity
A homeowner in Islip Road, Oxford, built a second-floor extension on his terraced house without serving the party structure notice the Act requires. His neighbour only found out once work had started, and sued him in trespass and nuisance over roof damage and…
All lofts and extensions stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.