PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Fattahi v Charles Grosvenor: No Notice, No Builder Indemnity

A homeowner in Islip Road, Oxford, built a second-floor extension on his terraced house without serving the party structure notice the Act requires. His neighbour only found out once work had started, and sued him in trespass and nuisance over roof damage and a gas Rayburn flue left unusable. She recovered a little over £10,000.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

19 December 2019 · Court judgment · Islip Road, Oxford · [2019] EWHC 3497 (QB)

What happened

Two neighbours owned adjoining terraced houses in Islip Road, Oxford. One of them hired a building company to add a second-floor extension. Clause 7 of the building contract said obtaining party wall consents was the customer's responsibility, and that the customer would be liable for the company's losses if they were not obtained. The homeowner did not read the contract and did not serve the notice required by section 3 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. His neighbour learned about the extension only after work had begun.

Without the Act's procedure, the homeowner could not rely on its protection. The neighbour sued him in trespass and nuisance, saying the works damaged her roof and made a gas Rayburn's flue, close to the works, unusable. He in turn brought a Part 20 claim seeking an indemnity or contribution from the builder.

What was decided

In Oxford County Court the judge found the neighbour honest and a significant part of her claim proved; she was awarded a little over £10,000. The claim against the builder failed, because the loss flowed from the missing party wall consent, which clause 7 made the homeowner's responsibility.

On appeal, Mr Justice Turner accepted that the trial judge had wrongly referred to the homeowner's non-delegable duty in the Part 20 claim, but held this made no difference because she had clearly understood the claim fell within clause 7. Her conclusion that proper compliance with the Act would probably have prevented the dispute was supported by the evidence. The appeal was dismissed on 19 December 2019.

Why it matters for homeowners

  • Raising or building on a party wall, as many loft and upper-floor extensions do, is notifiable work under section 2, and section 3 requires a party structure notice at least two months before work starts.
  • If no notice is served, the Act's rights to carry out the work do not apply, and the neighbour can sue in trespass and nuisance under the ordinary law.
  • Building contracts commonly put party wall compliance on the client. Reading the contract matters, because a builder's indemnity may not cover a missed notice.

What to do if this happens to you

The lesson: Serving a party wall notice is the building owner's responsibility, and your builder's contract probably says so.

Source

National Archives Find Case Law ([2019] EWHC 3497 (QB))

Related guide: read our guide on this topic

More lofts and extensions stories

Neighbour Loft Conversion Damage: Council Not Liable (2026)

16 June 2026 · Ombudsman decision · Bromley, London · London Borough of Bromley (25 023 147)

A homeowner in Bromley complained that the council failed to inspect a neighbour's loft conversion and ignored his requests for help after the works allegedly damaged his chimney and guttering and let water into his home. In June 2026 the Local Government and…

Windsor Loft Collapse Left Homeowner £200k Out of Pocket

17 September 2025 · News report · Springfield Road, Windsor

On 6 August 2020, during a loft conversion on Springfield Road in Windsor, the roof had been removed when the brick gable wall collapsed into the work area. Three workers were seriously injured and the first floor of the occupied home was destroyed. Two days…

All lofts and extensions stories · Latest party wall news

Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.