Zissis v Lukomski: How to Appeal an Invalid Party Wall Award
A homeowner in Birkdale Road, Acton, served a section 6 notice on her neighbour for planned works. The two surveyors could not agree, so the third surveyor made an award in 2004, which did not deal with the neighbour's surveyor's fees. When the third surveyor later declared himself incapable of acting, the neighbour's surveyor issued an addendum award on his own, awarding himself £15,825 plus VAT.
What happened
The owner of a house on Birkdale Road in Acton, west London, served a notice under section 6(1) of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 on her neighbour in 2003 for planned works. A dispute arose, each owner appointed a surveyor, and the two surveyors selected a third surveyor. They could not agree an award, so the third surveyor made one in February 2004. It did not deal with the fees of the neighbour's surveyor.
In September 2004 the third surveyor declared himself incapable of acting, and no replacement was appointed. The neighbour's surveyor then made an addendum award on his own, saying the homeowner's surveyor had neglected to act. In it he awarded himself £15,825 plus VAT, payable within 14 days.
The homeowner brought a Part 8 claim in the county court to set aside or vary the addendum award. The district judge found it invalid because the surveyors were not properly constituted, but dismissed her claim on the ground that it should have been brought as a statutory appeal under Part 52, and ordered her to pay costs on the indemnity basis.
What was decided
On 5 April 2006 the Court of Appeal partly allowed her appeal. It held:
- An appeal against an award under section 10(17) is a statutory appeal governed by CPR Part 52, and the Act's 14-day time limit applies rather than the usual 28 days. Because it is a rehearing, the court can hear evidence.
- A party may also challenge an award said to be invalid by seeking a declaration that it is a nullity.
- Having found the award invalid, the district judge should have allowed the claim to be amended or to continue, rather than dismissing it.
- The indemnity costs order was replaced with standard-basis costs.
Lord Justice Brooke referred the judgment for consideration of guidance on how such appeals and the enforcement of awards should be handled.
Why it matters for homeowners
Section 10(17) gives 14 days to appeal an award to the county court. Missing that deadline or using the wrong procedure can be costly. But an award made by surveyors without proper authority, for example by one surveyor acting alone where the conditions for that are not met, may be void and can be challenged as a nullity. Fees awarded by a surveyor to themselves are a common source of these disputes.
What to do if this happens to you
- If you receive an award you think is wrong or invalid, take advice immediately and diarise the 14-day appeal limit.
- Ask whether the surveyor had authority to act alone and whether a third surveyor was properly in place.
- Read our guides to appealing a party wall award, ex parte awards and how to dispute a surveyor's fees.
The lesson: Challenge a doubtful award within 14 days, and remember an award made without authority can be declared void.
Source
National Archives Find Case Law ([2006] EWCA Civ 341)
Related guide: read our guide on this topic
More notices and awards stories
Serving Notice on a Council-Owned House: Newham Delay
A homeowner in Newham planning an extension needed to serve a party wall notice on the house next door, which the council owns and lets to a tenant. He asked the council repeatedly for the right contact details, and said its failure to reply held up his…
Ombudsman: Party Wall Agreement Breaches Are for the Courts
A resident in Bristol complained to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman that her neighbour had damaged her wall in breach of a party wall agreement meant to protect her building. The Ombudsman declined to investigate. It said the Party Wall Act…
Takhar v Mohamed: Settlement Took Dispute Outside the Act
A basement at a house in Chigwell led to several county court claims between neighbours, which were settled in 2016 by a Tomlin order. The settlement appointed an "Agreed Surveyor" to decide compensation as if under the Act. That surveyor later awarded the…
Power v Shah: No Party Structure Notice, No Party Wall Award
In Power v Shah the Court of Appeal decided that surveyors cannot make a valid award under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 when the building owner never served a notice for the work. The case concerned works at a house in Bull Lane, Dagenham, including the…
All notices and awards stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.