Party wall surveyor vs structural engineer: who does what
A structural engineer designs the work (beams, foundations, underpinning, temporary support) and is appointed by you as an ordinary consultant. A party wall surveyor is appointed under the Party Wall Act to settle a dispute with your neighbour by an award, which often reviews the engineer's design for its effect on the neighbour's property. Most structural projects next to a neighbour need an engineer; you need a party wall surveyor only if the neighbour does not consent.
Side by side
| Structural engineer | Party wall surveyor | |
|---|---|---|
| Job | Designs the structure so it stands up and meets building regulations | Resolves a dispute under the Act by making an award about the notified work |
| Legal basis | Your contract with them | Appointment under section 10 of the Act |
| Who they serve | You (the client) | A statutory role: must act impartially between the owners |
| Outputs | Calculations, drawings, method statements, temporary works design | Schedule of condition, award, inspections, addendum awards |
| Needed when | Any structural alteration: steels, removing walls, new foundations, basements | Notifiable work where the neighbour dissents (or is deemed to) |
| Who pays | You | The surveyors decide (s.10(13)); usually the building owner |
| Checked by | Building control | Either owner can appeal the award to the county court within 14 days |
How they work together
On a typical loft conversion or rear extension:
- Your engineer designs the beams, padstones or foundations.
- You serve the right notices, describing the work, with plans and sections for any Section 6 excavation.
- If the neighbour dissents, the party wall surveyor(s) review the engineer's drawings for their effect on the neighbour: bearing on the party wall, depth of excavation, sequence of underpinning, temporary support.
- The surveyors may ask the engineer questions or for extra details. On complex work, they may require the design to be checked, or ask for monitoring.
- The award fixes the agreed drawings. Section 7(5) then requires the work to follow them.
The surveyor does not redesign your project. Their focus is the neighbour's property and the way the work is done. If they need engineering advice beyond their own expertise, they may take it, and the reasonable cost is dealt with under section 10(13).
Can one person do both?
It is possible for an engineer to be appointed as a party wall surveyor, because the Act only requires that the surveyor is not a party to the matter (section 20). But the GOV.UK booklet advises that a surveyor should not already be engaged to supervise the building work. An engineer who designed your scheme and will inspect it on site is, in effect, reviewing their own work. A neighbour is likely to prefer their own surveyor in that case. See who can act as a party wall surveyor.
Do I need an engineer if the neighbour consents?
Usually yes, if the work is structural. Consent replaces the award, not the design. Building regulations still require the structure to be sound, and building control will usually want calculations for beams, new openings and foundations. What consent removes is the party wall surveyor and the award, not the engineer.
Do I need a party wall surveyor if I have an engineer?
Only if there is a dispute under the Act. If the neighbour consents in writing to your notice, no surveyor is needed. If they dissent, or do not reply to a Section 3 or 6 notice within 14 days, surveyors must be appointed. See when do you need a party wall surveyor.
Where an engineer is especially important
- Basements and underpinning. Temporary works and sequencing next to the party wall. See basement conversion rules.
- Piled foundations near a neighbour, where vibration and pile depth matter. See piled foundations near a neighbour.
- Old or fragile party walls, where bearing a new beam may need spreading the load or strengthening first.
- Chimney breast removal, where the remaining breast or stack above needs support.
- Demolition that leaves a party wall standing on its own for a while.
Project by project: who you will probably need
| Project | Engineer? | Party wall notice? | Surveyor? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shelves, sockets, replastering on the party wall | No | Usually no | No |
| Loft conversion with steels into the party wall | Yes | Yes, Section 3 | Only if the neighbour dissents |
| Single-storey rear extension, foundations within 3 m and deeper than next door's | Usually | Yes, Section 6 | Only if the neighbour dissents |
| Chimney breast removal | Yes, for support above | Yes, Section 3 | Only if the neighbour dissents |
| Basement under a terraced house | Yes | Yes, Section 3 and Section 6 | Commonly, because the risk is higher |
The rights and notice rules come from the Act itself, on legislation.gov.uk.
Who to appoint first
Usually the engineer, or the architect who brings in the engineer. A notice must describe the work, and for excavation you need plans and sections, which come from the design. Serving notice on an unfinished design invites a later addendum award or a fresh notice; see party wall addendum awards.
A note for adjoining owners
If you received the notice, you do not need your own engineer in most cases. Your surveyor reviews the building owner's engineering information for its effect on your home. If your surveyor thinks independent engineering advice is needed, they will say so. Point out any existing structural concerns in your house before the schedule of condition is taken. You can shortlist surveyors in our party wall surveyor directory.
Frequently asked questions
Can my structural engineer be my party wall surveyor?
The Act does not forbid it, but if the engineer designed and will supervise the work, the booklet's advice against using someone supervising the build applies. Expect the neighbour to appoint their own surveyor.
Does a party wall surveyor check the engineer's calculations?
They review the design for its effect on the neighbour. Detailed checking of calculations is for building control, though surveyors may ask for a check on complex work.
Who pays if the surveyors want an engineering check?
The surveyors decide reasonable costs under section 10(13). On work for the building owner's benefit, that is normally the building owner.
Is a chartered building surveyor the same as a party wall surveyor?
No. Many party wall surveyors are building surveyors, but the role is a separate specialism. See chartered building surveyor vs specialist party wall surveyor.
This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.
Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free
Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.
We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.