PartyWallAgreement.org.uk

Chliaifchtein v Wainbridge: when the award's method statement is ignored

Chliaifchtein v Wainbridge Estates Belgravia Ltd [2015] EWHC 47 (TCC) is a High Court decision showing that a party wall award's method statement is a binding obligation, not a guide. A developer probed the ground with a driven steel beam rather than the specified pin, then dug a hole at least two metres deep beside the party wall without the trench box the award required. Mr Justice Coulson held the developer in breach, said the neighbour was justified in seeking an emergency injunction, and ordered the developer to pay his costs.

Local Surveyor Match
1,920 listings across England and Wales, nearest first.

What happened

The claimant owned 10 Grosvenor Crescent in Belgravia. The defendant developer owned numbers 11 to 15 next door and was redeveloping them at a cost of about £243 million.

A party wall award dated 27 November 2014 included a method statement for probing for piles and removing obstructions. Probing was to use a standard breaker with a 3-metre pin. Any obstruction was to be removed inside a trench box, pushed down as the digging went on so the sides of the hole stayed supported.

Before the injunction, the developer had driven a rusted steel beam into the ground to probe for obstructions and left it there under rubble. On 8 December 2014 its contractors dug to get it out. The top snapped off, so they dug a hole to free the rest. The court found the hole was at least two metres deep and went into the existing ground, not just loose rubble. Trench boxes were on site, as photographs showed, but were not used there.

The neighbour applied without notice to the developer for an injunction, which was granted that day and kept in place two days later. The judgment deals with whether there had been a breach and who should pay the costs.

The questions for the court

Was the developer in breach of the party wall award? Did the neighbour act too hastily in going to court without notice, so that he should lose his costs?

What the court decided

  • Breach: Yes. The probing was not done with a pin as the method statement required, but by driving in a steel beam, a percussive method the statement did not allow. The beam was then dug out without a trench box or any other support for the sides. The judge said the developer was removing obstructions "without having regard to the method statement".
  • Scope: The developer argued the method statement only covered obstructions that existed before probing, not ones it had created. The court rejected that. The statement covered obstructions created by the works, and that obligation would be implied anyway.
  • Injunction: An application without notice should be a last resort, but on these facts it was justified. The neighbour was entitled to protect his property.
  • Costs: The neighbour was awarded his costs. Combined costs on both sides were just over £60,000.

Why it matters in practice

The method statement is part of the award. On big projects, surveyors attach engineers' method statements and drawings to the award. Chliaifchtein shows a court will hold the building owner to them strictly. Doing the work a different way, even a way the contractor thinks is fine, is a breach.

You cannot argue your way out because you created the problem. The developer put the beam in the ground itself. The court said that made no difference: removing it still had to be done safely and by the award's method.

Injunctions are available and fast. The neighbour got an order the same day. Courts do not grant these lightly, but where an award is being breached in a way that risks a party wall, they will act.

What to do differently

If you are the neighbour: 1. Read the method statement attached to the award, or ask your surveyor to explain it. 2. If you see work that looks different, photograph it with the time and date and tell your surveyor immediately. 3. If there is a real risk to your building and the contractor will not stop, take urgent legal advice about an injunction.

If you are the building owner: 1. Give the method statement to your contractor and make compliance part of their contract. 2. If the ground throws up something unexpected, stop and ask your surveyor and engineer before improvising. 3. Keep the specified equipment on site in use, not just present.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if a builder does not follow the party wall award?

They are in breach of the award. The neighbour can seek an injunction to stop the work and claim damages for any harm. In Chliaifchtein the court granted an urgent injunction and ordered the developer to pay the neighbour's costs.

Is a method statement legally binding?

When it is incorporated into the party wall award, yes. The court treated compliance with it as a strict obligation. That includes situations the developer had not anticipated, such as obstructions it had created itself.

Can I get an injunction without warning the other side?

Courts allow it only in urgent cases, as a last resort. Here the judge said the neighbour's application without notice was justified because a deep unsupported hole was being dug next to his party wall in breach of the award.

Does this apply to small domestic projects too?

The principle does. Any award that specifies how work must be done is binding in the same way. Domestic awards are usually simpler, but if yours says how deep, how wide or how supported an excavation must be, the builder must follow it.

Related guides

Read the judgment: Chliaifchtein v Wainbridge Estates Belgravia Ltd [2015] EWHC 47 (TCC) (National Archives)

Last updated: 4 November 2026. This page is general information about the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (England and Wales). It is not legal advice. Every property and dispute is different, so take advice from a party wall surveyor or a solicitor before you act.

Download the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 free

Get the full, up-to-date text of the Act as a PDF from the official legislation.gov.uk record, with our plain-English guide to every section, sent straight to your inbox.

We use your email to send the Act. See our privacy notice.

Contact us

Send us a message and we'll reply by email.

We only use your details to reply to you. A quick human check runs when you send.