Builder Jailed After Brighton Basement Dig Collapsed a House
In February 2015 a builder digging out a basement beneath a house in Brighton's North Laine undermined its structure. When cracks appeared he did not follow a structural engineer's advice, and part of the gable wall collapsed while the ground floor fell into the basement. Neighbouring homes were evacuated and the area was cordoned off. He also failed to report the incident to the Health and Safety Executive.
What happened
In February 2015 work began to extend a house in the North Laine area of Brighton downwards by digging out a basement. The builder undermined the structure as he dug. When cracks appeared, he did not act on the advice of a structural engineer about how to deal with them. Part of the gable wall then collapsed and the ground floor fell into the basement.
Neighbouring properties were evacuated and the area was cordoned off because of the risk to nearby residents and passers-by. The builder also failed to report the collapse to the Health and Safety Executive as a dangerous occurrence.
What the court decided
He pleaded guilty at Hove Crown Court to breaching regulation 25(1) of the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2007, which deals with keeping structures stable, and regulation 7 of the RIDDOR Regulations 2013 for failing to report the incident. In April 2018 he was sentenced to five months' imprisonment for the first offence and two months for the second, to run concurrently, and ordered to pay £7,000 costs.
An HSE principal inspector said basement work must be properly planned to ensure the structural integrity of the building throughout the works, warning that badly done work puts workers and the public at risk of serious injury or death, and stressing the impact on homeowners whose properties are damaged.
Why it matters for homeowners
A basement usually means digging close to, and often below, the foundations of the neighbouring house. Under section 6 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, excavation within three metres of a neighbouring structure and deeper than its foundations, or within six metres where it cuts a 45-degree line from the foundation base, needs a notice at least one month before work starts. Underpinning a party wall is covered by section 2. If you dissent, surveyors can require method statements, engineers' details and monitoring, and the building owner can be asked for security for expenses under section 12. None of this replaces the contractor's legal duty to keep the structure stable.
What to do if this happens to you
- If a basement is planned next door, ask for the engineer's drawings and temporary works design, and consider appointing your own surveyor rather than an agreed one.
- Ask for movement monitoring and a clear procedure if cracks appear.
- If you see sudden cracking, report it immediately to the building owner, surveyors and building control.
- Read party wall rules for basement conversions, section 6 excavation notices and security for expenses.
The lesson: If a basement is planned next door, ask to see the engineer's temporary works design and what happens if cracks appear.
More excavation and collapse stories
Kirupakaran v Ibrahim: £1.5m Party Wall Claim Struck Out
In June 2026 the Technology and Construction Court struck out a claim of about £1.5 million brought by the owner of a terraced building in Croydon Road, London SE20, after works next door damaged it. The neighbouring former pub was being extended and…
Neighbour Extension Collapsed Tenant's Decking: Clarion Pays
A Clarion Housing tenant's garden decking collapsed into the neighbouring garden in March 2023 while the neighbour was building a rear extension. The neighbour's works, which began in December 2022, had also blocked drains and destabilised her fence. A party…
Richmond Terraced Homes Collapse During Basement Works
Shortly before 3pm on 10 September 2024, two terraced houses on Lower Mortlake Road in Richmond collapsed while undergoing refurbishment. The roofs caved in and the upper and ground floors were badly damaged. The houses were part of a redevelopment into 14…
Hackney Rebuild Collapsed; 20 Evacuated From House Next Door
On 24 June 2023 the rear of a three-storey semi-detached house with a basement on Gloucester Drive, Hackney, collapsed from roof level to the ground. The house was being reconstructed and nobody lived there. London Fire Brigade said the collapse was believed…
All excavation and collapse stories · Latest party wall news
Stories are written by PartyWallAgreement.org.uk from the linked judgments, decisions and reports, which we check before publishing. They are general information, not legal advice.